What are your thought about Tess? Is she a strong character? Does she make good choices? What are her motivations for keeping her past from Angel Clare? Does Angel love her? How does she feel?
Angel is different from his brothers in many ways. First, he has more freedom to choose his own future; he is the only brother who thinks independantly and is not just following his parents' wishes.
In regards to the original post,I think that Tess was a simple country girl who had to face the cruel realities of the outside world when Alec took her advantage of her. In my opinion, she isn’t necessarily “strong,” but she is attempting to become stronger through the things that she has experienced, which is exemplified through her choice to try and allude Alec, as well as what he stands for.
I believe that Angel really does love her, but Tess feels that if he were to find out about her past encounter with Alec, then he would no longer want to be with her because she isn’t “pure.” But then again, why would Angel care that Tess “corrupted” herself if he did immoral things himself?
Just to ask a question, in Phase 4, chapter 28, "That she had already permitted him to make love to her he read as an additional assurance...love-making being here more often accepted inconsiderately and for its own sweet sake than in the carking, anxious homes of the ambitious, where a girl's craving for an establishment paralyses her healthy though of a passion as an end," states that Angel and Tess have already “made love.” Is this to be taken as it would be in today’s world, or does it simply refer to courtship?
Contrary to what Justin said about the strength of Tess, it seems to me as if, at least initially, Tess's altercation with Alec actually caused her to lose strength. Before Alec took advantage of her, Tess was willing to isolate herself from her family’s support in order to raise money to purchase a new horse. This took strength. After what Alec did to her, however, she soon retreated into her old home. She hid from the public. Slowly, she adjusted to her situation and strengthened. It was the humiliation, guilt, and critical eye of society that caused her to grow in strength, not the event with Alec. Finally, despite Tess’s increase in strength, we find in Phase 4 that she is still quite unable to forget the past. In my opinion, strength is the ability to be knocked down and still get back up and persevere. Thus far, I’m yet to see Tess do that.
Sorry Mitch, but i agree with justin on this one. I believe that Tess has grown stronger throughout our readings so far. We knew Tess when she was a simple country girl, and seeing her now in the text readers can tell that she has grown stronger. The whole situation with Alec was a temporary set back, but the situation helped prove her strength when she ended up having a son. Tess cared for him with dignity and took him to the fields with her to nurse him. Even though he was illegitimate and a mistake in society's eyes, she cared for him and loved him. Also the fact that her son ends up dying, and she has to bury him is a test to her strength. Most mothers having to do this would simply give up and not be able to carry on with life, but Tess shows her strength and maturity by decorating his grave and still being able to complete tasks in daily life.
Ahhh... Sorry Nick and Justin, but liken in everything else in school, I think Mitchell is correct on this one. You see, I believe that the whole reason Tess has to move from her home in the first place to the Talbothay's dairy farm is so she can forget her past. She needs to leave her whole life behind her, because she is not strong enough to deal with the views that people will have of her in her present society. As Mitchell said, because she was not strong enough to go out into public, she secluded herself and only went out during the nights, which demonstrates that she had not grown stronger, but rather Alec had "broken" her, and made her weaker. As well, contrary to Justin's belief, I think that the reason that Tess does not marry Angel is because of her weakness, not her strength. I think that Tess is ashamed of the fact that she does not consider herself "pure" anymore, and she is too afraid to tell Angel about her past. I just think that the reason that Tess does not initially marry Angel is not because she is strong and true to her values, but rather she actually wants to marry him, but she is too ashamed of her past and too afraid of what a marriage would cause.
I definitely see what Mitch and Tim are getting at, and I agree with most of what you two are saying, however I still think that it truly does take strength to ATTEMPT to overcome one's past. And in opposition to what Mitch said, I believe that Tess really did "get back up" after being knocked down by being able to go out in public and take the criticism from everyone around her. I guess my point is that it takes a strong person to be able to ignore what people are saying about them, but an even stronger person to try to lead a normal life with that criticism.
In conclusion, kudos to Mitch and Tim, you've made me even more on the fence about my views on Tess than I was before. Good job guys...
Thanks Justin. Now seeing that the argument over Tess and if she has become "stronger" has basically concluded, I want to address Angel, and how he differs from his brothers. I believe Angel is very independent, and that his parents are somewhat prejudice. His family wants him to marry a women, Mercy Chant,not because he loves her, but because it would be beneficial for his social status. Angel has a lot of strength to somewhat "rebel" from his parents, and not just follow the same path his family did. He is strong in that he has his own beliefs, and the strength to pursue his own goals. Angel is very independent and strong-willed, and differs from his brothers and family greatly due to these characteristics.
To redirect all this Tess strength discussion to Angel's marriage proposal(s), I just have to say that I wanted to throw my book out a window when I saw that Tess refused Angel not just once, but basically every time he proposed to her or brought up the possibility of their marriage. I guess I sort of understood why Tess declined, but I feel like if she truly wanted to put her past behind her, she'd just tell Angel about her experience with Alec and move on to a happy life with him. It makes me wonder if Tess is strong or if she really is weak. If she was strong, she'd tell him the truth. Her refusals definitely made me think that she was on the weaker side at one point, but when I read the end of phase 4, it sort of changed my mind. I'm still on the fence regarding her strength, and I think that what happens after she tells Angel the truth and the decisions that she makes will determine whether she really is strong and can truly put her past to rest.
I guess this is one thing we can agree on Tim. I also believe that Angel is a very independent character and is somewhat of a rebel in the eyes of his family. But, I think the reason for this background is to show the reader that Angel is not the perfect person everyone claims that he is. Angel's character was put in the story to contrast Alec but it is also important to note that he is not completely good. Dont get me wrong Alec was much worse but Angel also posesses bad qualities because of his troubled past. Angel has these qualities to make him less god-like in the reader's eyes and more relateable to Tess. There would be no point in putting Angel in the story as Tess's love interest if he was perfect because this would make him untouchable.
Actually now that i think about it im doubting my agreeing with you Tim. I think that Angel is a fake rebel because he still cares about what his parents think. That is the only reason why he is trying to change Tess. If he truely didnt care what his parents thought about Tess, then he would stop trying to foce his beliefs on her. Overall i guess i believe that Angel's beliefs are too strong and that he is still trying to compete with his brothers for acceptance from his parents.
p.s. the physical portion of this fight can take place in lit second period tomorrow...be there
Jessica - if you wanted to throw your book across the room then, wait until you read Phase 5!! You'll need to think about that telling Angel and clearing everything up idea!
Returning to the issue of the strength of Tess, which I seem to be attached to, I think that at the end of phase four, Tess proves even weaker than before. For an extended period of time, Tess debates whether or not she should tell Angel about her past. In her heart she knows that telling him is the only way that she can get on with her life. Unless she is accepted by Angel for what she truly is, she does not feel she can be in a relationship with him. Then, after they marry, Tess yearns to tell him. In the end, the only time she can tell him is when she feels that she has been “let off the hook.” When she learns that Angel has also been sinful, she assumes that her sins will no longer be a big deal. Then, finally, she admits her sins. To me, strength is the ability to admit your wrongdoings and suffer the consequences. Tess can not muster the strength to do this. Instead, she waits and waits. Finally, when the consequences seem to have removed themselves, she admits what she has done, but this is a sign of weakness, rather than strength.
Hello there fellow Tess readers. In answer to the OH MY! revelation at the end of Phase Four that Angel, himself, has violated someone as Alec did to Tess and Tess' subsequent exposure of her traumatic ordeal I would have to say "Finally". As you guys mentioned previously, Angel cannot be so pristine and perfect as to be unattainable (don't forget the foibles of the last character who was described as "nebulous"). So it does not come as a surprise that he has done such a heinous act. But his confession is probably good for Tess because it allows her to completely expose her past. But for heaven's sake, it took a ridiculously long time and I believe that them waiting till after they were married to tell their secrets will wrought an immense load of emotional suffering throughout the rest of the book. But we can always hope and prey that the tragic life of Tess will get better, can't we? (Though it probably won't, no actually, will clearly never improve.)
Tess didn't tell Angel because of selfish reasons. She wanted him to continue to think of her as pure. She wanted to continue to be loved by Angel. Furthermore, I fonud it quite clear that Tess WANTED to tell Angel and didn't have the strength to do so, rather than wanting to tell and resisting. These are all signs of weakness.
jessica, i completely agree with you. i was really mad.
But that part of the story just kind of proves a point about how not strong she is. Tess can't even move on from her past and marry a man that actually treats her with dignity and respect up until this point. Question: how many times have you heard a story of a woman who has been raped and just gets over it and continues on with her life? Mitchell, i agree with the fact that I truly don't beleive that she was picked herself up from this experience. If she is supposedly "so strong", then why can't she tell of her past and move on? It is taking her all of her strength to tell Angel, and honestly, i don't know if she should trust him yet. A girl is entitled to her secrets, and i don't think she should be sharing them unless she is ready to be able to hold her head high and stand firm on the ground by herself.
In response to Mrs. Brown's original prompt, Tess's response to Angel's proposal is to lie and avoid. Initially, Tess responds to his proposal by stating that she only wants to love, but not to marry. Then she changes her defense by claiming to protect him from the scorn of his parents, who expect him to marry a woman of high social status. Later, she says she cannot marry him because of what his friends would think. She behaves this way to prevent Angel from marrying an impure woman, but she should have told him the truth from the start. He wasted time by continually seeking her affirmative response because she could not be honest about her past. I understand that it is difficult to reveal such a HUGE life secret, but if she really loves him she should be able to tell him such things- versus living haunted by a lie. Basically, I understand the reason for Tess's response to the proposal, but cannot agree with her actions.
I believe that Tess has grown weaker throughout the storyline of the novel. At first she resists all of the actions and innuendos that Alec sets upon her. Yet, as time passes, on the extended ride through the woods her vulnerability is revealed. From this, it seems as if Tess is allowing others to operate her life, as well as settling for the belief that her people support- that is, that "It was to be". From the primary action that was performed in the woods, there is a portrayal that "...social chasm was to divide our heroine's personality thereafter from that previous self of hers...", whereas never again would Tess return to her previous nature. Subsequently, hereafter, it appears as if Tess is submissive to Alec, even though she does not have romantic feelings toward him. Thus, the fact that Tess cannot stand up for herself as an individual despite tragedy creates a weak individual. In my eyes, if she wishes to be strong despite the event, she needs to utilize it as motivation to rise above conflict.
Also- the fact that Tess chooses to not reveal certain pasts and truths to Angel displays weakness. In order to have a strong relationship, one must share truths instead of denying or dodging them.
A question Mrs. Brown brought up today in class is, "Is it wise for Tess to listen to her mom and keep her past a secret from Angel?" In response to this I believe that it is very un-wise of Tess to listen to her mom and keep her past to herself. Earlier in the work Joan Durbeyfield wanted Tess to marry Alec D'Urberville for all the wrong reasons, the main one being for money. When Tess listened to her mom's advice about going and staying with the D'Urbervilles it ended with the rape of Tess. This displays Joan's inability to think through her thoughts and thus should not be taken seriously. Therefore I believe it is not wise for Tess to listen to her mom. Also, now that I have read about Tess and Angel getting married, I believe things can only get worse because Tess listened to her mom and did not tell Angel of her past. Sooner or latter the truth will have to come out but i doubt Angel will accept the fact that Tess was raped whole heartedly and may even begin to look down upon her.
As I read phase 5, my views of Angel defineatly changed. When he makes his second appearance in the book at the farm, I thought of him as someone that would help Tess get stronger. He is/was affluent, kind, and hard working, he seemed like the kind of person that would stick by her no matter what. After reading phase 5 though, I was really disappointed with how he reacted when Tess told him of her past. When he married her he made it sound like he would stand by her no matter what the circumstances, but when he leaves her just like that it really lowered him in my view; especially after he had relations with an older woman in London and he actually had a choice unlike Tess. Angel comes off as a progressive man for his time period, but is it possible between his decisions to become a farmer instead of going to college(likely the better prospect) against his parent's wishes and to leave Tess simply signs of his immaturity? Would he have asked Tess to marry him so soon with so few details if he wasn't so naive?
I totally agree with Ryan. Especially since Angel made his decision to have relations with a stranger, while Tess was totally vulnerable and nable to protect herself from the situation. It is incredible how much Angel changes from the veiw of the reader from phase 4 to phase 5, and it made me realize that Angel is not much less selfish and arrogant and disrespectful than Alec, if at all.
Concerning whether Angel loves Tess: I think he absolutely loves her, no question. We see that when he is about to take Izz to Brazil and suddenly stops, choking up, and says that he cannot take her. It is obvious that he loves her, but his own pride and stubbornness stops him from admitting (or realizing) that he is wrong.
I'm really disappointed in the characters of this novel. First, Alec turns out to be a big jerk. Then Tess finds this wonderful man who is in love with her, and he ends up being a hypocritical jerk. I am especially disappointed with Tess. Although she has been taken advantage of by her family and Alec, she seems like she has no back bone. she allows others to walk all over her. I am hoping that with this quarrel between Tess and Angel, she stands up for herself, and learns from her many mistakes.
Caitlin, I agree that Tess looks weak right now. I believe in this part of the story Tess is portrayed as a weak character. For example, Tess begs for Angel's forgiveness after she tells him about his past. I believe that if she were a strong character, she would not need to appologize to him. Personally, I think the fact that she is appologizing is stupid. But, in my opinion if Tess were a strong character she would not have to run after Angel when he goes off into the night. In fact, I believe if she were a strong character she would be able to realize she is right and maybe walk out on Angel for a while. Everything that made me think Tess was a strong character has has been wiped out by this scene, leading me to think that Tess is a weak character.
As the novel progresses, all of us are disappointed to find out about how the major characters change in the novel and especially phase the 5th. However, i don't agree with the fact that Tess is weak. If Tess was weak, she wouldn't be able to live the life and do the things that she does. In my opinion, she is strong because she holds on to her beliefs and principles even in times of struggle and when in conflict with Tess. I think that, that Angel is the weak one, because he is unable to deal with Tess's confession. Tess knew that something bad was going to happen but she is always willing to compromise, where as Angel just always wants to see the good side of thins and is unable to see the bad and deal with it; that makes him a weak character.
I'm sorry if I'm backtracking but I need to talk about the end of phase the fourth and the beginning of phase the fifth. Angel admits to her that he spent two days with a stranger (probably no longer a stranger though), and Tess feels that she can finally come clean to him about the rape. So she does and he can't deal with it. ARE YOU KIDDING?? I understand that the social expectations for men and women were different in those days, and I give credit to Hardy who faced those head on, but as a female, I wouldn't have been able to deal with Angel Clare. I would have left him, but Tess doesn't have the strength to do that. So Angel goes. He has to leave her because he cannot bear to despise her. He goes to a different continent because she was raped. She couldn't control what happened to her and he couldn't control what happened, why does Angel think that leaving her is somehow going to help either of them?
In my opinion, Tess is a weak character. When Angel says that he cannot deal with the fact that she was raped, she follows him around. She even goes so far as to say that she thought about ending her life. She's thinking suicide because the man who claims to love her can't deal with the fact that she was raped. That doesn't make her strong. It makes her extreme in her reactions, but it doesn't make her strong. One way that she would show her strength is to leave Angel. If he can't love her because of something that she couldn't control, who needs him.
I completely agree with Amanda; no matter what time period or culture, is it really fair to leave the one you love because you can't handel their problems yet you expect them to handle yours? I think it is completely unfair for Angel not to handle Tess' problems. As Amanda said, Tess' situation was not her fault and Angel should be able to get over his now apparent chauvinism (though this may be too harsh of a description) and continue to love her. Hardy really captured changes in personaliity, especially on page 183 when Angel says after finding out Tess' secret, "I repeat, the woman I have been loving is not you". It is now prominant, especially to the reader, that the Angel we have previously been whitnessing was a persona. Therefore, i believe it is right for me to say phase five completely changed my opinion of Angel.
How have my views of Angel changed since reading Phase the Fifth? Well, for starters, I really love how accepting and sympathetic Angel is. NOT really! Actually I think how he reacted to Tess' revelation is a load of cuck. I agree with Amanda in that I acknowledge that those were different times back in them ol' days but come on, the fact that he can't be around her in fear that he may grow to despise her is ridiculous. And, instead of just leaving, he has to be so snide as he slips out the doorway and out of his commitments. He acts as if something has been done unto him which is as lucid as me riding a miniature pony on the highway. He has no right to blame Tess (especially if you remember that she tried to tell him her secret before he said "I do" and should thus take his situation with a grain of salt (how cliche). She isn't a different person as he seems to think and it does not give him the right to act moronically (asking Izzy to go overseas with him instead of his wife). His emotional response and his following reactions all seem to prove how imperfect he is and how vain every living person truly is. We can love others but we still only think of that person in regards of ourselves. How could Tess do such a thing to him? Well, how could he do such a thing to the women he so desperately pursued?
Im response to the first question about Tess being a strong person. i do not beleive that she was being strong, but i also think that not many people could be strong in that situation. After what alec did to her she tried to hide it as much as she could-this is not necessarily the "strong" thing to do-but i beleive that it is what anyone in that situation would do. I beleive that by her moving to the dairy farm represents her trying to run away from her past, and i do not blame her at all for doing this. I do think that Tess should of told Angel about her situation before they got married, but i can understand her concern about what he would think of her. I beleive that if she was strong in that situation she wouldn't of tried to her past and would of told Angel much sooner about what happenend. Although Tess did confess to Angel about what happened, i still beleive that he does love her. If he didnt, i dont think that he would send her money and still keeep the minnimal contact that they do have. He also seems to regret his harshness towards her by saying how "if only she [she] told me sooner". I think he understands that he screwed up, and so did she, and they both need to be forgiven for that.
To Mrs. Brown's question about how my views of Angel have changed... I agree with many of the above bloggers that the view of Angel has shifted to the polar opposite of how he was introduced. I'm waiting for another turning point that may reveal why Hardy chose to make him this phenomenal person when first introduced and then the total characterization of Angel does a 180. His angelic nature and almost God-like characterization was hopeful for the reader; I thought Tess was on her way to a happy ending). It was horrible how Angel reacted to Tess' confession. Considering his actions, he's response to her story of the rape was cruel. It is also interesting how (from a literary standpoint) Hardy juxtaposes Alec and Angel. First, Alec is the bad guy and Angel is brought in as the savior. Then when Angel leaves Tess, Alec reappears at the end of phase the fifth. I am not sure why Hardy does this, but it may foreshadow something about how the relationship Tess holds with both Alec and Angel may change. No matter what happens, I am no longer a fan of Angel. His leaving Tess and reaction to her rape are awful and it left a bad taste in my mouth after this sudden turn.
In response to angel's transformation in phase the fifth: I completely agree with Michelle, Monique and Amanda. I was shocked to find that Tess's acceptance of Angel's previous affairs was not reciprocal. It is hard to believe that anyone could be so narrow minded as to believe that a rape could possibly be the woman's fault. Not to mention that Angel considers Alec to be Tess's "husband in nature", despite her complete loath of Alec. In my opinion Angel's affair before their marriage is incomparable to the relation between Alec and Tess. Angel has completely reversed his previous disposition to become the same as, if not worse than, Alec. His outbursts of emotion reveal him for the man he truly is. Although he still has feelings toward Tess(otherwise he would have divorced her)her confession caused him to treat her as more of a servant who cannot be trusted. Overall, it is appaling to me that someone who seemed so good, acts completely opposite under a specific circumstance that should not even apply.
Something else that bothers me about phase the fifth is the way which Tess responds to Angel's overreactions. When Angel first reveals his anger toward Tess over her rape, she takes it and begs him for forgiveness for being RAPED?!?!? I cannot even begin to understand her reasoning. Perhaps she wishes to keep their marriage together at all costs, but still, her actions have left me puzzled. The second reason Tess shocks me in this phase, is when she considers killing herself because she feels bad that about the effects that her rape had on Angel. Again, I was baffled when I read this. I'm not sure, but perhaps this is how people in this time period viewed women's rights (as having none), but it is just unbelievable to me that a woman should be punished for being raped. This is yet another example of Tess weakening throughout the book, proving that she is not growing stronger as a person, but sinking into submission.
While reading Phase the Fifth I became outraged by Angel's reaction. I agree with you Heather, how can someone be upset with someone else because they were raped. Rape is defined as "any act of sexual intercourse that is forced upon a person" therefore it is absolutly ridiculous that Angel is ashamed and angry at Tess.
I think it is interesting though because his anger can be seen in individuals in our society. I think that back then it was a lot worse and that women had way fewer rights, but if anyone remembers in health class or self defense the teachers always tell you its not your fault if you're raped which implies that there might be people today who try to blame you for putting yourself in that situation or what not. So my point is...I don't think our society has changed all that much.
Tess I think is also very frustrating. I am mad that she didn't tell Angel before about the rape. If I were him I would be really mad too. How do you marry someone who has left out such an important detail. When I read Tess I feel like I'm watching a scary movie where I just want to tell the characters what to do because their every move just leads to negative outcomes.
Throughout the reading so far I agree with what heather says about Tess. She growing weaker as the story progresses and doesn't seem like she will change. If somebody is raped it means that there was no consent from one of the parties, in this case it was Tess. Then when Alec gets angry at her, she says she is sorry and wants to kill herself when it was beyond her control.
What I want to know is what Angel's true motive behind going to Brazil is about. Angel is having a big problem and I wonder if he is trying to get away from Tess. They both have a terrible past, so why is Angel trying to run from the problem instead of fixing it?
Reading Phase the Fifth made me extremely angry. Angel's reaction to Tess's confession was both uncalled for and hypocritical. How does he have the right to be mad at her for what happened? Tess was raped. Alec preyed on her and cornered her into a situation where nothing could be done to escape. Tess was a child; extremely naive to the evil ways of men, so she really can't be put at fault for what happened to her. Rape is not only physical abuse but mental as well. What happened to her was almost tragic, so Angel had absolutely no right to react the way he did.
Also, Angel confesses to having had an affair with an older woman, which in his eyes in completely forgiveable. But for some reason, Tess's rape is not forgiveable? I hate that society puts a double standard on certain situations. It's okay for a man to sleep around at his will, but if a woman is not pure, in any sense of the word, she is considered to be a bad person.
I feel the same way Ariel does. Angel should have never acted the way he had. he abandoned Tess in her time of need. He just got up and left. Everyone is innocent until proven guilty. Tess should not be treated as a bad person but as a good person in a bad situation. I think the only wrong and bad person here is Angel.
coming back to Angel's character...When i think back at all that has happened in Angel's life and all the decisions he made, i come to the conclusion that his character has not changed at all. Angel has always chosen to take the easiest way out of things and to make his life as easy and comfortable as possible. i think that a lot of it has do to with his background. His family is wealthy and he did/does not really have any problems and always 'got what he wanted'. I think that never before in his life had he had to deal with something like Tess's confession and that simply overran him. He did not know what to do because in his life up to then he had never faced hardships really and always got what he wanted, at least that was what he thought. Tess on the other hand had to deal with hardships all her life and she is 'used to' having to deal with struggle; furthermore in her life, Tess always worked thinks out to the best of her ability and even though she might not have always been happy, she still knew how to deal with struggle. That is why i think this marriage was doomed for failure and also the fact that they act totally different in this time of crises is no real surprise.
In responce to Fredrick, i think that the angel is portrayed as a contrast to Alec thus forcing us to think that Angel was different and kind.As i was reading i had two different view of him.Angel's reactions to the other dairy workers actions and thoughts of him tells us that he does not resist to the different treatment he gets from them. i think that he contrast his own views of disapproving family name and wealth by his acceptance to the different behavior that he get from the dairy farmers and the owner of the farm. the second view was that he was the kind and supporting person that tess needed. I really think that Angel is the weaker one who cannot accept the fact that tess is not all that perfect.The fact he expects tess to live with the past in which he was invovled with an older women while he cannot accept the fact that Tess against her will was taken advantage of by Alec shows that he is the weaker one. i also agree that it should not have been a big surprise that angel has reacted that way because he is someone who expects things to work in his favour and so far in his life he had all the benifits.
In response to how my views have changed about Angel...... I found a very strong passage in Phase the Fifth about Angel's true feelings toward Tess. When, on page 198, Angel's sleep walking and talking is being discussed i found that this event is the basis to Angel's true thoughts of Tess. Like Tess states in this passage, Angel has a tendency of sleep talking and walking about prior events that happened that day because his conscience refuses to let his days experiences end. Thus when Angel found out Tess's past his true feelings come out in his sleep talking and walking and he says sadly out loud "'Dead! Dead! Dead!'". This reveals that the Tess he used to know is know non exsistence and essentially dead to him because her past shadows over any other characteristic he fell in love with in Tess. Therefore we find that Angel cannot get over Tess's past and we learn that nothing she can do will change that. Lastly, also within that passage, we learn that Tess realizes Angel's true feelings because she knows that his sleep talking and walking are a continuation of his stream of thought from prior events. Overall i found this to be a great passage and one to keep in mind as we move forward in the text.
I beleive that a major part of Phase five is when Angel is leaving to go to Brazil and asks Izz to go along with him. Izz tells him that Tess "would have laid down her life for 'ee" and this seems to have an impact on Angel. As soon as he replays that in his mind, he decides that he should not bring Izz along with him to Brazil. I think the fact that he decides not to take Izz to Brazil shows something about his charachter, maybe foreshadowing something between him and Tess at the end of the novel.
The collapse of Tess & Angel's marriage certainly has two sides to it, and I would like to address the one that we have focused on less frequently. What could Tess have done to prevent Angel from 'abandoning' the commitment they made to eachother? After Angel shows disdain for Tess' past - the fact that she was raped, and then gave birth to a child that died shortly afterwards - she completely submits to his will in the hopes that her submissiveness will draw him back towards her. This effort fails miserably. Tess then endures Angel's wanton cruelty, until they part ways indefinately. Could not Tess have attempted to maintain her dignity, instead of groveling in front of Angel - the one who actually sinned - for forgiveness she did not even need?
I would have to agree with Ryan. Much of Tess's suffering is self induced. She allows the guilt of her past rule over her present life. She feels that she is always in the wrong. It is not Tess who should be punished for events that are out of her control, but she remains submissive to Angle. Tess says "i agree to the conditions, Angle, because you know best what my punishment ought to be,"(204) She is not in control of her own life. Tess is letting the men in her life ultimately control her happiness and well being. Maybe Tess should make some decisions that will benefit her, instead of worrying how they will reflect upon Angle.
In response to Becca's question, I do think this could be considered social commentary, or just commentary on human nature in general. From the few details i know concerning this time period, I believe that Hardy is stating that women too often give up their sense of independence and self-importance when they enter what they hope to be a "successful" relationship. Since the marriage turned sour only hours after the rings were exchanged, Tess panics. Her idyllic relationship with Angel seems impossible now, but because of her deep love for him, and her still-strong desire to be committed to him, it never occurs to Tess to seek happiness elsewhere. Divorce was something still frowned upon in Tess' time, so I am sure other moral beliefs related to marriage and "purity" were entrenched throughout society at that time.
Purity seems to be an important attribute in a women. Maybe the reason we view Angles reaction towards Tess so negatively is because we live in a different time period. It seems a sin to inflict such pain upon a delicate young woman's hart, even though you have committed the same sin. It always has been, and it always will be more socially excepted for males to engage in certain scandalous behavior, then it is for women. In modern times women like to be though of as strong and equal, but in the time of Hardy women were supposed to be submissive and weak.
Do you think that Tess's submissiveness would be perceived as the right thing to do during the release of the novel?
dear becca, an interesting question you bring up. I don't necesarily know whether Tess's submissiveness would have been the right thing to do; most importantly, i think it was her only option. Historically, the spirit of women has obviously evolved to the point where we are considered equally to men. But in the age when Tess was written, i don't think there would have been much of another true way to react. I imagine that it would be an extreme minority of women that would have acted differently than tess had the same experience happened to them. They didn't have options like we do. The options and opportunities available to people (in this case women) have increased dramatically as the world has gone on. Among other things, i think it's this modern day opportunity is the reason our world is so advanced.
So i tell myself- the opportunity we have in our world was created by US...if tess HAD acted differently, would she have created a positive opportunity for herself to prevent bad things from happening in her future?
I agree with Jenny on her response to Becca's question. I believe Tess's response was more of a must rather than the right thing to do. During the time this book was first published, 1891 anyone wanted to know, women didn't have much of a choice in regards to being submissive to their male counterparts. I think Tess made the right decision in her mind, based on the culture and time period. And now that decision would be viewed as maybe weak or the wrong thing to do. But we must consider the culture of the time period, in which women were not equal to men and did not have the oppuritunties they have now. So Tess in her mind, did what she thought was right in order to survive and not become an outcast in society. Now looking back we can argue that she should have been more assertive and not taken it, but she probably thought she had no choice.
In response to Jenny's question I think that if she had been assertive and not submissive the result would most likely be negative for her. I think that could have occurred is that her response of being assertive is that she becomes more of an outcast in this society which during the time is ruled by men. Like mentioned before men during this time period, were in charge and did what they want pretty much without punishment. It is even seen in the novel Alec rapes Tess and she instead of telling authorites like people would now, keeps what happened hidden. And most likely if she did assert herself would probably would have been dismissed. So I think that by acting assertive could have caused her more problems than being submissive. Speaking against men in that time period usually caused women to be outcasted and chastised. This could have created a hostile enviroment for Tess. The possiblity of having men who run society hate or black list you could have ruined your life and any oppuritunity you had could have been shattered. And if that happened she would probably have to leave the place and move somewhere else to escape that situation. So I think acting and being assertive poses more of a risk than a benefit.
I also have to agree with Becca and Jenny. Within the time period of Tess women were seen as merely objects that men could acquire. The women was meant to be pure and honest and really had no say in their own lives. Angel had some form of control over Tess, he was her husband after all and at this time that meant everything, and since he decided that he could no longer live with her it seems like her only option was to accept it. What could Tess really do anyway? Angel had made up his mind about how he felt towards her, it isn't like she could convince him to forgive her (I don't think forgive is the correct word, it wasn't her fault). Angel had decidedthat he could no longer bear to be with Tess and there really isn't anything that she could do but submit to his decision.
Angel and his brothers differ in the respect that his brother's chose the path set by their father and Angel decided to do his own thing. Angel's brother's lives seem to be better than his because though Angel is living the way he wants he is making mistakes and paying for them. For example, if Angel just gave in and married Mercy Chant than he would have been assured of her purity and wouldn't be on his way to Brazil to escape his wife. In choosing to follow their father, Angel's brother chose an easier life for they really don't have to make any decisions. The brother's may be letting the father lead their lives but they don't have to worry about making life changing mistakes- even if they do, their father will be there to help them. Since Angel chose to lead his own life, it seems like he can't really go back to his family for support when things go wrong because he didn't heed their advice and made decisions based on his heart where his family made them with success in mind. I'm not saying that being told what to do is the best life today, but at this time knowing that your family would be there to worry about things and essentially do your thinking seems like a better life than running away from the one you once loved.
In response to Sean's comment; yes, Angel did decide against bringing Izz with him to Brazil, but the fact that he even asked her to accompany him allows us to see more of his true character (along with abandoning Tess)than that decision.
As I read on in Tess, I find it more prevalent that there is weakness present. First, Tess is willing to do anything for Angel in order for him to accept her now that he is aware of her past. Tess' amount of dignity in this passage is to the point of zero, whereas she diminishes herself fully by willingly sacrificing all of herself for Angel. Also, later on throughout the book, there is a weakness in attendance that is presented in a different fashion. The subtitle of Phase the Sixth clearly states the idea- that "The Woman Pays". That is, when Tess begins to have interactions with Alec once again, the text notes and implies that the mere fact of Tess' attribute of being a female is hereby an unfortunate disadvantage. This is because while Alec is involved in the same episode that occurs in the past, he moves on and experiences a "conversion" into a religious persona. He even gains the consent of a preacher. Yet, Tess remains a social flaw, even though the episode that she experiences with Alec is a far lower degree her fault than Alec's. Furthermore, the simple point that Alec has the nerve to exploit Tess is a sheer demonstration of disrespect of the female.
Apologies if I’ve repeated a previous topic explicitly posted (I don’t think I did, nor did I mean to); same to if I used quotes from your previous comments without permission…
As I gleaned over the past comments and discussions, I couldn't help but notice the assertions and defenses of Angel's actions as well as the idea of Tess's strength. Regardless of whether or not Tess's problems or desperation is self-inflicted (are they?), a reader must admit that she seems to continually fall into situations where she is left with no well-defined path of recovery to follow. In that, I think that we’ve been fooled by our author into supporting Angel Clare, while despising his supposed foil, Alec D’Urberville. While we’ve been looking at the handsome, well-mannered, self-questioning man, we’ve also been directed to look away from his flaws. To be honest- the fact that Angel has left Tess, somewhat on her own, doesn’t surprise me. Why? Simply because he (Angel) is a lot more alike Alec, than we’ve given him credit for. Timmy, Amanda and Monique all hinted at it previously, stating “it made me realize that Angel is not much less selfish and arrogant and disrespectful than Alec, if at all,” or similar ideas. In this discussion alone, Angel has gone from a character we love, to a character we love to hate, and now ends as a character with the benefit of the doubt. Yet we have to question, whatever happened to the girl that he slept with previously..? Did she end up in a similar situation as Tess? Given, she wasn’t raped for 48 hours (we assume) but still – How does a glorified man such as Angel leave her to fend for herself…and now he leaves Tess… How does Angel’s decision to become a farmer mirror Alec’s to be a minister? Angel was characterized by Nick as a “fake rebel” because he still cares what others think of his actions… Couldn’t you characterize Alec the same way? Neither of them has much of a family support system, but both come from well-to-do families. Tess seems to attract a particular type of man. The fact that perhaps Angel is a few years ahead of Alec on the time-line (in terms of personality maturity) is troubling. How similar do you think Alec and Angel ultimatley are? Do the circumstances under which they’ve acted excuse certain faults?
I have very mixed emotions about each character in this story. They each act one way which causes the reader to believe that's who they truly are, and then some event happens where my point of view of them is totally distorted. i have no idea what to think of the characters in this story anymore. For example, Angel was originally a sweet guy who i thought was perfect for Tess. (Maybe he still is perfect for her? i don't know.) then he abandons her because she came clean, which was a jerk move, but THEN he tells Izz he cant take her with him to Brazil because of Tess, which is nice and almost shows a bit of his fidelity to Tess.
I must admit that Michael brings about a good point. Tess, over the course of the novel, has attracted two men with disturbingly similar qualities. I agree that the author has obviously set them as foils (Angel's name only adds to that fallacy), but in the past few sections, they are just variations of the same. Alec may be the lesser of two evils! At least he is open about his flaws, where as Angel's are more hidden behind his fabulous facade. We have been drawn to his character since his introduction. Does anyone remember meeting him? He was checking out EVERY girl dancing around in a white dress! He is totally a womanizer, just like Alec. Perhaps Angel did knock up the weekend fling of his past, and maybe she is just like Tess: striking, not from a wealthy family, considered of "poor breeding," and the seemingly stereotypical small town, field hand girl.
But, if Tess attracts these men to her, mustn't she also be drawn to them? She acknowledges them, courts them, and puts everything into her dysfunctional relationships. I think her men-problems also stem back to her father, the town drunk. It is common for a woman to end up in a relationship with a man similar to her father. When her mother was young, she was like Tess (beautiful, small town, etc.). Isn't it possible that families then are rather cyclical? They recreate similar arrangements and then play the roles of their parents. I am not asserting that this is the case throughout the history of every family, but if the role Tess is playing is the only role she has been exposed to, how would she know to behave differently?
I agree with Lydia about the characters (especially Angel) being rollar coasters. Throughout the plot, be are pushed one way then pulled in another when it comes to our opinions on the characters. A good example of this would be when Angel sends money to Tess to care for her, yet leaves the country. If he was completely heartless (as many have hinted), he would not care for her wellbeing; yet, he DOES. However, this care is very very limited since he refuses to accept her apologies. For me personally, i feel very little sympathy for Angel; i refuse to try understanding his reaction. It was selfish and hypocritical.
Yes, Tess could have acted differently...in theory. I agree the time period has a great impact on her character as a whole, and maybe she WAS trapped.
But, the idea that her suffering is self-induced is absolutely intoxicating. Wouldn't that change the entire story? This would mean that the cards have always been in Tess' hand. Therefore, we would be forced to turn away from dwelling on the immorality of the men that traipse around after her (or away from her I suppose) and study her with the criticality reserved for psych ward worthy patients.
Instead of the naive country girl, repeatedly abused by upper class men, we would essentially be left with a masochist furtively plotting her own demise!
Michael, I think that your questions brings up a good point, which I disagree with Sophia on. I feel that Alec and Angel are very different. First, Angel does check out every woman at the dance in a white dress, however this does not make him a womanizer. He is still a single man at this time. Shouldn't he be able to check out other women? I think that even though Alec and Angel may have hurt or used Tess, they are very different because of their circumstances. Alec simply planned on using Tess for his sexual desires, whereas Angel actually liked Tess. This is obvious through the rape of Tess compared to the marriage of her. One of the most common qualities between both men seems to be their arrogance, believing themselves to be higher than Tess. This is seen through Angel's lack of forgiveness for Tess. Once again, I disagree with Sophia on the fact that she is drawn to these men. Its seems to me that she was only really drawn to Angel, whereas her "relationship" with Alec was merely one way. Although I do like the thought about her problems stemming from her father. From what is stated above, both men do have some similar qualities, yet I feel that the circumstances make the audience slightly more lenient with Angel. Alec performed his own actions out of lust, in comparison to Angel who performed his out of shame. Now a question: If Angel is so willing to run away, did he actually ever love Tess the way the audience was meant to believe?
I strongly disagree with Dylan. Angel and Alec both took advantage of a woman or participated in illicit relations with one. For all we know, like Sophia said, Angel could have completely taken advantage of whoever he slept with for those 48 hours. I agree that Angel isn't a womanizer, but I think that his wealthy background, along with Alec's, and their position as superior men in society make them acceptable in the eyes of society during Tess's time, and almost in our time as well. The only way that the characters differ is that Alec owns up to his mistakes and tries to reform himself while Angel keeps his secrets from Tess and doesn't even seem as ashamed of what he did as he should be. Both men want Tess in some way; both are in love with her. However, I don't think that Angel really loves Tess herself; I think that he loves the idea of her and the purity that comes along with that. Regardless of whether Angel got whoever he had sex with pregnant and regardless of the different kinds of love they have for Tess, both men are similar. They are arrogant and self-important and deserve an equal amount of hatred or dislike from the reader.
Answering Dylan's question, I definitely think that the reader's idea of Angel's love for Tess has completely changed. If he truly loved Tess herself, not just her looks or "purity", he wouldn't have abandoned her. Marriage means that you stick together for better or worse. Obviously Angel doesn't love Tess the way the audience was supposed to believe if he ran away, like a coward, to Brazil. I understand that he feels betrayed, but really? Brazil? That's on a completely different continent. Yes, he probably needs some time to recover, but he essentially did the same thing. His love for her has completely transformed.
I definitely think that Michael's comparison of Angel and Alec was both right, relevent, and thoughtful. Both men had affairs with women they had no intentions of marrying as well as treated Tess poorly. But I would have to agree with Dylan that we, the readers, tend to overlook Angel's flawed character. I think the inner-romantics in all of us want to believe that somewhere deep inside of Angel lies the respectful and wonderful man that Tess fell in love with at the farm.
In response to Dylan's question, I do believe that Angel loves or loved Tess in a true way. But i think that he just didn't want to hear that there was any other man in Tess's life before him. He is a human being. We are stubborn and resentful, and tend to hold grudges for periods of time. I would like to think that he will, at some point, get over himself enough to go back and treat Tess the way that she deserves to be treated.
to Dylans question i have to say that i think that if Angel truly loved Tess then he would be able to overlook what has happened in the past and be able to forgive her. i think you do find that being with a person is accepting them for all their flaws because that is what makes them perfect. Tess was able to deal with the fact that he himself has not always been the greatest, so why shouldnt he feel the same? to some extent though he does love her because he did consider not leaving and going back to find her.
to compare angel with alec though is a different story, alec just wants someone to be with and im not so sure that he actually will love that person. angel is the type that will find something that he can relate to and have a relationship with.
In response to Dylan's question and Jessica's comment.
I agree with Jessica that the audience has very different views of Angel after he ran away. But now that Alec is back in the text as a main character again (as we get into phase the sixth) it's again interesting to see different "sides" to him. At first, he seems transformed, like his work in the church and with his faith have helped him become a better man. But as he talks and begs and pleads, I just find him annoying. He took advantage of Tess once, and I can only hope it doesn't happen again. But I think he is mostly back to being a womanizer and a control freak. I think his encounter with Tess at this point in the story will bring out in him the characteristics the audience is most familiar with.
And I don't think I believe that Angel really loved Tess. I think he was made up to be a phenomenal rescue after Alec. But when he chose to run away, that doesn't scream committment. He has other intentions, as we learn when he conefesses to being with another woman, and I don't think his intentions with Tess could have been far off. Maybe it is in the context of the time period that makes it hard to gauge whether Angel loves Tess. He may have, but in our current society, when you run away from the past or the truth, it mostly means you don't care enough to stick around.
Something else that I find interesting as we move into phase the sixth is Tess' hesitation to write to Angel. On page 257 (chapter 46) there is a brief paragraph that describes Tess writing a letter to Angel and then simply putting it away, thinking he will not care. I'm wondering if this relates back to her being a stong character. She is married to the man and cannot find it within herself to write to him. She doesn't have to speak face to face, doesn't have to listen to a response, just has to let him know what's going on. If she cannot tell her own husband of her feelings and desperation, how will she ever find anyone else to trust. I understand that she's a difficult position, but I think she needs to tell Angel what she's feeling. We have said in class that because of the time period, the man is more or less supposed to be dominant and the woman compliant to his wishes. If that is what Angel wants (since we can somewhat agree he too loves the control) then he should respond and come to protect her. She'll never know until she finally sends a letter.
In response to Jessicas opinion concerning Dylans comment... Angel really does love her, he says to his mother " she lives what paper-poets only write" (pg131) meaning that Angel is captivated by everything Tess does, he loves the way she is, her outlook on life, he loves her for her personality.
Alec doesnt really own up to his mistake, and feels no remorse until we see him again in Phase 6. And you are mistake about Angel having no remorse, on page 180 he says "you will see what a terrible remorse it bred in me when...I myself fell." He also explains that he felt the same torture and desire to confess himself to Tess in the same way that Tess did. "He seemed to be her double!"
Finally, how can you say Angel does not love Tess when he chokes up at the mention of her love for him? As well as when he was sleepwalking and demonstrated the love that he could not show in his waking hours.
In agreement with Michelle, i also find Alec extremely annoying. From the very beginning of phase the sixth, i find his turn towards religion false and conceited. It is so quick that it is unbelievable to the reader. Alec's infactuation with Tess slowly turns to obsession, with multiple examples throughout chapters XLVII, XLVIII, and L. Throughout this entire phase, i am creeped out for Tess. I think that Alec's obsession is over the top and makes the reader uncomfortable. As much as Tess has been pushing away Alec, there seems to be underlying foreshadow that eventually Tess will be sucked into the web Alex has spun around her. even if it is just for the sake of her family, i fear that Tess' life is going to take yet another turn for the worst. If only Angel could have understood Tess is at no blame for what happened to her, Tess' life would not be as miserable as it has turned out.
Theres too much drama in this book. People need to chill out man, Angel in particular. "oh no, my wife had sex with another man before she married me?! Oh wait, so did I(with a woman though)...But I'm gonna shun her for life and go to Brazil with some other chick anyway." What a joke, thats not cool at all. I think that one of the main reasons I find myself saying that the characters need to relax can be based on the difference in time periods, similar to Michelles response concerning Angel's love for Tess.In Tess's time period,previous sexual relationships before marriage were looked down upon and purity of a woman was valued. In our society, not so much, at least I believe. But on the other hand, I agree with Michelle in her statement that Angel did not really love Tess. In all honesty I hate Angel. And I hate Alec to. They're both idiots when it comes to treating women, believe me I know ;). Basically we all know by now that they want to get some. However, Alec is the kind of guy who is more strightforward about it whereas Angel is the kind that will stick around, walk the walk,talk the talk and hope all goes well when the time comes to go to bed at night if you know what I mean. Come to think of it, I hate Tess right now as well. What a pushover. Stop letting guys play around with your heart and start sticking up for yourself and demand a little respect. That is all.
to back up my response, i've heard that in today, the percent of Americans who have premarital sex is about 90%, so based on that how do you think Angel's reaction would be viewed in todays society? I think he would probably seem kind of crazy for ditching Tess over something like that.
Well, since everyone should be reading Phase 6 tonight, I feel it's appropriate to comment on it. Emotion plays a big role in my perception of each character in this section. First of all, in Chapter 47, I felt proud of Tess when "she passionately swung the glove by the gauntlet directly in [Alec's] face" (Hardy 267). I hate the way Alec is so pushy while pursuing Tess, and it's nice to see her sticking up for herself. However, I felt angry reading this section when Tess seems to give into Alec and believe he may be her only hope. It upsets me to read that Alec believes that by helping Tess she will forgive him for raping her. Also, as irritating as the seperation between Angel and Tess is, I'm rooting for them, and Alec's seduction makes me hate him even more! Except that is not to say that Angel is not at fault- he frustrates me. Why doesn't he just come home already?! He needs to get over himself and fulfill his duties as a husband. In addition to feeling proud of Tess and angry at the men, I was sympathetic while reading the letter Tess writes to Angel on page 271. She finally finds courage to plead for forgiveness and profess her unfaltering love for Angel. Furthermore, I pity Tess for the hardships within her family [pathos :-)]. Overall, my emotions regarding occurences in Phase 6 has changed or intensified my perceptions of the characters in this text.
In response to Matt's question, personally I think that in today's society Angel would probably be called stupid for leaving a girl that's as beautiful and angelic as Tess is for a reason like that. Then again our society is extremely different in it's view on divorce. On the extreme end of things we have the celebrity crowd who marry and divorce constantly. This is emulated by the public in the mindset that "the stars did it so it must be ok". However, in our society people usually leave over money or just plain hating each other, not the girl's virginity. Besides, if we did go by that, then the large majority of the women in America and probably the world would never be married. Going back to Angel, he would be called stupid for leaving her because of his reason but not looked down on for actually leaving her. Again this is because the society of Tess cares alot more about marriage than we do today.
A huge smile crossed my face as I saw that becky had quoted: "she passionately swung the glove by the gauntlet directly in [Alec's] face" (Hardy 267). If she hadn't I definitely would have had to have brought it up. To all you guys who insist Tess should take a stand- is that what you meant? In response to the first question about Tess posted (has she become stronger throughout the text) this part of the text can be taken two ways. 1) YES! she finally grew a backbone that leads to a brain and did something that she can be proud of! (that she still apologizes for..) OR 2) No! She's let her emotions get the better and is acting out of anger/desperation. She's weaker and now she is just getting by. This shows it clearly. Which is stronger in your opinion (1 or 2)? I personally think that by this action she display her weakness as a person. She lost her composure. Sure - it was provoked following unfortunate circumstances.. But still - she lost it. She's been worn.
In response to Zoe.. With the ways things are going in Tess' life i guess we can say that the reintroduction of Alec is a foreshadowing of something bad about to happen. His "love" for her really has manifested into an obsession as seen in Phase 6 where he finds her on multiple occasions and refuses to give up on asking her to marry him. Alec honestly has become a stalker and appears almost constantly everywhere Tess goes: her garden, the church Tess and her family sleeps in when they cant find lodging, Candlemas, and plenty of other places. He also seems to be doing almost anything to get Tess to like him, becoming a clergy member, offering his house to her family when Tess' father dies, giving up on being a clergy member when it shows that Tess could care less, helping her in her garden while her mom is sick, etc. His willingness to do ANYTHING to get Tess to like him (even force her) is almost pathetic to the point you almost feel a little sorry for him. At this point I can see Hardy taking the story in two different directions. Either Angel makes it back in time and saves Tess from Alec or Tess does something by herself to rid herself and her family of Alec. I personally am leaning toward Tess doing something that gets rid of Alec but also makes her life worse because the majority of the book is basically about Tess' suffering how crappy her life is. It doesn't seem likely that Hardy will give Tess another large period of happiness like before she told Angel her secret and the life she enjoyed with him. So my question is this, do you think Tess' life will get worse than were its at now or do you think that Hardy will end the story in a positive "happily ever after" way?
Wow, Michael. That is quite the conundrum. However, I feel the question of Tess's strength is a wishy-washy concept. She appears solid, then cracks later. It depends on how one views actions (in regards to time periods and gender-appropriate ideals). In accordance with Michael, I don't think that after Tess's "uppercut" it really proves that she has become stronger. In my opinion, some kind of passionate outburst, verbal or physical, is the kind of attention Alec wants. It's what he feeds on, and by her acting out in aggression it just entices him more. No one can really justify striking someone else as a righteous action to prove a point. She pretty much hits Alec to shut him up because she doesn't want to hear him whine about how his personal shortcomings are her fault. Tess needs to rise above her scapegoat position, but she won't do it by smacking people, even if they deserve it. In my opinion, the stronger person would have taken the higher road and realized that she is better than stupid squabbles about nonsense with cretins that can't move on with their lives.
Does anyone else find that Tess continually seems to be portrayed as a scapegoat for everyone else's personal failures? First her father and mother blame her for not doing her duty to the family by marrying a noble cousin, then Angel can't accept her rape but is relatively guilt free from his little escapade, and now Alec can't get past her "haunting image" corrupting him out of his religious burst of zeal? I'm really finding Hardy to be obnoxious in this sense, but it is just proving a point that women were pretty much doormats to contain dirt and other unpleasant things from ruining the bigger picture. Props to Hardy for realizing the degradation of women, but will he ever make Tess rise to the occasion?
I agree with Chryssa, it seems as though Tess is always used as a scapegoat in the three cases of Alec, Angel, and her parents. The story is starting to get old and repetitive as far as how the events rise and fall in action and we are given the same portrayal of women as nothing but mothers and housewives during the time period. After the first few phases i hoped that the plot would become more interesting, but it is just more of the same in a new scenario.
In response to Zoe, i am at the same point in Tess right now, and i think that Alec is acting very unlike himself. But hey, this is back then, who knows, maybe people's personalities were capable of radical change in life philosophies. Afterall, this is the same society in which a man will not have a non-virign for a wife, however himself is not pure either. I think that Alec's behavior is foreshadowing of something bad to come, but through all of the twists and turns that have been going on throughout the novel i think it is capable of going both ways, in unexpected favor of Tess, or predictable disappointment for tess.
This comment is a little off the topic of the blog but through out the book since Tess' child died, i have wondered why Hardy has not mentioned her sorrows about her child later on in her life. I mean I am aware that she is trying to move on (or run away) from her troubles; but a person can not just forget about a being that they pushed through their utterus and gave life to. Maybe this is just Hardy's way of revealing a different phase in Tess' life, and mentioning the child would keep her stuck in the past. But I do just find it slightly strange that Tess never thinks about her child besides when she tells Angel her awful past. And when she tells Alec about his child.
I agree with what Chrysa said about Tess being the scapegoat, but i never really realized it until i read her post. I don't think that Hardy is portraying her like this just because she is a woman though. I think it has more to do with how she is-i do not think that she is being strong-not her gender. I think that if she was stronger as a person she would stand up for herself and not be allowed to be the scapegoat. She should stand up to Angel because he was more in the wrong than she was...she had no choice to get raped. I agree that she is used as a scapegoat a lot, but i do not feel like it is just because she is a woman. I beleive that he is just portraying a weak character to maybe emphasize how tough her life has been. I do agree with Chrysa though that Hardy is making her look like a big scapegoat in almost every situation.
Through the beginning of phase six it seems unclear of Alec's true intentions. Has he really found God? Do you think that Alec is a wolf in sheeps clothing?
No matter how hard I try I really do not like Tess. She is an annoying little whinner baby to me. Especially when Angel was pursuing her, Tess would just not let herself be happy. And now she is without a husband, and back to where she started with Alec being a fool; claiming to have found God. I find the characters in Tess very simlar to other literary works like The Scarlett Letter. Tess is very similar 2 the chick who had to wear the letter (her name escapes me at the moment). And Angel is like Hawthorne. Angel starts to become mentally unstable, and corrupt like Hawthorne. What is it about love and lust that brings about characters downfalls?
In response to Michael M and everyone else who answererd his question:
I definitely think they're many similarities between Alec and Angel. To what extent they are similar is a debatable, but I won't dwell on that. I want to look at the big picture. It seems to me that the social commentary Hardy makes with the Alec/Angel situation is that no man is guiltless of fault or sin. Throughout the book, I've noticed countless instances of symbolism that would suggest Hardy has a disdain for religion, well Christianity specifically. By building Angel up to be a glorified, nebulous character and fooling the audience into believing Angel will be the one to save Tess, Hardy succeeds in demonstrating the true, undeniable nature of man. Almost to say, that in dire (sp?) situations, man reveals his true colors.
Personally, I think everyone picks on Tess because they're viewing her from a present day standpoint. In retrospect, it's very easy to understand why Tess is the way she is. In the 1890s, the words "women" and "right" were seldom put together, unless one is giving directions or idealizing a perfect woman.
If one accounts for the audience that the book was targeted towards, Hardy's obviously trying to play upon the emotions of women who have been hurt by codes of man. The audience sees how the selfish whims of society treat women like Tess. Yeah, it'd be great if Tess was like, "Whatever, I don't need Angel. I can be my own person without family or spouse" but that was unheard of for the times. Even today, some women can't bring themselves to do that.
Wow! What insightful comments today. I love the strong opinions whichever way you feel toward Tess or Hardy! This is just what I had hoped for in your involvement with the text.
One thing that angered me about this book is how Tess is being blamed for the incident that happened between her and Alec. I do not think that Angel has the right to be mad at her because he did the same thing only willingly, woman or man it is inevitably the same act. Tess did not want this to happen to her and she had no way of stopping it, so why is she punished for something she had no control over? I think that it makes a good topic to talk about in discussions about the book and helps develop the book, showing the reader the way women were viewed. But, as a topic, I fully disagree with it and it angers me knowing the double standard that we have in society back then and today, that men can get away with the exact same thing a woman does, but the woman is punished for it.
Throughout Phase Six Alec keeps coming back to Tess, begging her to marry him. My question is is why is doing this now after all this time? Does he really love Tess or does he just want forgiveness from God for what he has done? Tess is angry that he has become such a religious man because she thinks he has done this on account for what he did to her, so he can promise himself a spot in heaven by becoming a religous man and asking for forgiveness. Does Alec really deserve a "spot in heaven" after what he did to Tess? Causing her so much pain and suffering, even years later.
"Tess is very similar 2 the chick who had to wear the letter (her name escapes me at the moment)" -Chelsea
Hester Prynne?
Anyways, Rob and Chrysa were talking earlier about Tess' role as a scapegoat. While I think this is an important way of viewing her at this point in the book, it bothers me that no one seems to be talking about what the book is screaming at me. Tess was wrong! I am not trying to be insensitive, she has had a terrible history. Nonetheless, is Angel really such a bad person for being bothered by Tess' secrecy with regards to her past? Wouldn't you want to know if your fiance had been raped and had had a child before she met you? I for one would have felt hurt that she had not trusted me enough to share with me one of the most significant events of her life.
Note that this is not because of her history itself, it is her lack of trust that is important.
as to what caitlin is bringing up, i think that alec might have grown up more in the time that we havent heard from him. i mean who knows what he had gotten into when we didnt hear from him. if he became more involved with the church, or his mother actually started caring for him he might have realized that he needs to be more caring to those he loves. and with that he is trying to win tess back over. or maybe he is very jealous of the fact that angel married her first. i really dont know.
Caitlin has a valid point in saying that Tess faces a double standard with regards to what is acceptable for men to do and what is acceptable for women to do, and in reminding us that Angel had the luxury of a choice in the matter.
At the same time, we must remember that Angel was more straightforward about his actions than Tess. Is this because he trusts her more, or because as a man he can act without fear of the consequences?
With regards to Tiff's post I don't really trust Alec because of Tess' history with him. He has not truly reformed as much as he thinks he has--if he truly cared about her he would apologize and then stay out of her life.
Like john just said, i think that being straightforward is beneficial in the end. i can see where alec keeps coming back to tess because he loves her, and in part i do think this is justified. i admire his willpower and determination to win over tess; however, he tends to go about doing this rather arrogantly and way too forcefully.
in the end, i'm thinking i admire angel more for the way he handled his situation with tess. though he went a little too crazy about tess's history, i suppose it's legitimate because of the time period. and most importantly, angel seems to have a great consideration for tess. his thoughts and actions don't belittle her or treat her like a prize like alec's. Even seperating himself from her, i believe, was a decision angel made after serious thought to not only his best interest, but to tess's. he avoided other alternatives that would have been far more ruinous to both of them. sooo classmates, do you agree?
I think that alec should of never left tess in the first place. It was very hipocritical of him to leave her in the first place for what she had done. he had done the same thing and he left her just because she waited awhile to tell him the truth. She really does love him alot and she shouldnt let herself give in to him and let him come back into her life.
Also in response to what Chelsea F said a little bit ago about tess and how she didnt like her becuase shes a whiny little baby? I dont think that is true at all. i think that she is actually quite tough being able to make it through all the things that she has had to go through in her life. she was pretty much raped by alec and had a baby and everything and she was able to make it through that and allow another man into her life. and then after she did so he hurt her and left her after she needed him the most and she loved him so much. so i think that tess is rather tough and has great perserverence and i thinkk she should not let alec back into her life no matter how much he begs but i know it must be hard for her because of how much she loved or loves him.
In response to Jenny, I think that Alec keeps coming back to Tess because he loves her but it is kind of like he is stalking her. He just shows up at different places where she is. He expects her to completely forget that he raped her, and forgive him and possibly actually marrying him. I think that Alec hasn't really changed that much he is just disguising himself so it seems like he is a better person.
Everyone has been talking Alec down so much, which is understandable considering what he did to Tess earlier, but if you think about it, he is going through the exact same thing as Tess. Alec is asking for forgiveness and for Tess to forget his past, to judge him on who he is now. Even though Hardy portrays he demonically even now, Alec looks to me a lot like Angel did when Angel was trying to win Tess's hand in marriage. Angel is being a wuss over in Brazil, too childish to face his problems and solve the situation at hand, while Tess and Alec both are trying to win forgiveness. Wouldn't it be hypocritical to hope Angel forgives Tess, while hoping Tess never forgives Alec?
In response to josh r, i agree that Tess is not really a baby, she is pretty strong. She has been through a lot over the course of the entire book. She was raped, and then had a baby who died not long into its life. After finding a man who actually respects her, she is plagued with the guilt of everything with Alec. I think that Angel is very hypocritical because he told her about his "fling" and expected her to forgive him, but when she tells of her misfortune he blows up. As much as I could hope that Angel will realize that he is wrong, and come back to Tess, I don't really think that it will really happen. I think that maybe deep down he is not really husband material.
I agree with Katie about how Alec hasn't changed. He may have said that he's been "enlightened", but I think that was obviously a bunch of crap. He's still the same. He obviously wants Tess even more than he did when he was obsessed with her at first because he can't really have her now since she's married. I think that Alec's obsession or love, whatever you want to call it, has gotten worse. Some of the things he says hints that he might even view her as property. For example, he says, "'Remember, my lady, I was your master once!...I will be your master again. If you are any man's wife, you are mine!" on page 267. In addition, he also tells her, "'Mind this; you'll be civil yet!'" on page 294. Alec also takes advantage of a weak spot: her family. I don't think that it is fair that he tries to make her give in to him by saying that he'll help her family, which definitely needs help, especially after her father dies. Alec hasn't changed in the slightest bit; he's probably gotten worse.
In response to brooke e's comment, i agree completely. although it seems rather strange that we advocate the forgiveness of alec considering his inappropriate actions in the past, i see the "hypicritical" point you are trying to prove. It seems this book is filled with hypocracy. First, when Angel runs to Brazil, vowing never to forgive Tess and telling her what a terrible and unexcusable thing she has done- yet he too has done the same things. I feel strongly that this reflects the nature of Victorian society. Men and woman were held to double standards, and Hardy makes this clear. This is exemplified each time Tess encounters Alec, portraying her as a temptess and resposible when clearly this is not so. Thus, the victorian era seems filled with hypocracy and inequalities. And yet... doesn't it seem permissable that this hypocracy continues? I do not blame Tess for not forgiving Alec, because i feel his act was inexcusable, taking from her one of the few rights she has as a woman in the victorian era. However, I feel Angel needs to forgive Tess as he doesn't have such grounds to be angry... as he is the hypocrite himself. So wouldn't you agree, that even hypocracy has standards and limits of what is acceptable and what isnt?
I agree with John R in that Alec should apologize and stay out of Tess' life but i dont think that would ever happen because of his obsession with her. He seems to have changed in his religious views but when it comes down to being with Tess and not being with her those views that he holds now are out the window. After reading phase the sixth i think that Alec might be a stalker as someone else said and that his obsession for tess is unhealthy and that he should just move on and accept that she is with another man now, even though he is not there (Angel).
In response to Morgan, I just dont see why Tess doesnt forget about Angel like he has forgotten about her. He does not forgive Tess for her actions and though im not sure whether Tess knows about what Angel did...? but i think that that would be a more than acceptable reason to forget about him and move on but as Morgan was saying it was the Victorian Era and everything was different and they had different views on these things. Also there was the thing that Alec should not be angry at Tess because he has no right to be. I agree with this and think that she did not harm Alec as much as he harmed her so that she was right in telling him to go away and that he shouldnt have gotten mad and kept on being persistent in his actions.
In response to Sanjeev J: I understand what you are saying, and this is my initial reaction as well. But after considering it further i have decided that Tess has very little to lose. In her time of need, if Angel will not accept her, provide for her, and love her... then why not take another chance with Alec? He obviously is willing, and right now she needs some security, as marriage to him would provide. It seems that Tess cannot get worse off or more unhappy as she is basically identityless as each phase continues. As far as the self respecting thing to do, tess should realize she doesn't need men in her life (and clearly from her past she would be much happier that way)... yet whether it be due to time period or her strength of character, this doesn't seem like an option. Tess should not allow Angel to make her miserable, especially from so far away... i feel like it is time she does something for herself, and if alec is truly the temptation that she writes about to Angel... then perhaps he COULD be just what she needs. (But to be clear, i'm still not an Alec fan!!!)
I completely agree with Katie M. In class we've described Alec as a "creeper" and I think he proves that true now more than ever. He pops up constantly and even has gone so far as to ask Tess to marry him. I don't believe he's been "enlightened", but instead sees it as a way to get closer to Tess- or so he thought.
Morgan, what you say makes sense, but im not so sure i agree. I concur that Tess needs to get over it; it really is ridiculous that she has milked this sympathy for so long. However, im not so sure the way to go about this is through marrying Alec. His religious epiphany is completely fake; he will not provide support and love, but rather more mental abuse. He makes her feel vunerable (in a negative way) and she can do better. She should be able to turn her pain and misery around WITHOUT the help of a man. Yes i kno her family could use the financial help, there must be other options that do not involve Tess losing her dignity.
well how much more value does dignity have over your own family that you see suffering in fron tof your eyes!!! i believe that at that situation i would sacrifice my own diginity inorder to help my family. tess's first reason for working for Alec was to help her family with finance!! so i think that dignity has no value over a family in extream need!!
Education: Bachelor of Science in Education with English and Speech certification; Masters of Liberal Studies with English and History as majors and Art as a minor.
Experience: I teach 12th grade English at Aurora High School including the Advanced Placement and International Baccalaureate Programme courses. I have been a teacher for 23 years.
personal: I am married and have two sons, ages 12 and 13. I love to read and enjoy many genres. My family also enjoys camping, biking and outdoor activities.
125 comments:
Here you will all make comments about the reading assignment, about other comments, or about class discussions.
This is my comment.
How do Angel and his brothers differ? Which life is better?
Explain Tess's response the Angel's marriage proposal. What is her reason for her behavior? Do you agree?
At the end of Phase Four, what revelation does Angel make to Tess? What does she reveal to him?
Who wants to talk about Tess on Monday morning!
Angel is different from his brothers in many ways. First, he has more freedom to choose his own future; he is the only brother who thinks independantly and is not just following his parents' wishes.
In regards to the original post,I think that Tess was a simple country girl who had to face the cruel realities of the outside world when Alec took her advantage of her. In my opinion, she isn’t necessarily “strong,” but she is attempting to become stronger through the things that she has experienced, which is exemplified through her choice to try and allude Alec, as well as what he stands for.
I believe that Angel really does love her, but Tess feels that if he were to find out about her past encounter with Alec, then he would no longer want to be with her because she isn’t “pure.” But then again, why would Angel care that Tess “corrupted” herself if he did immoral things himself?
Just to ask a question, in Phase 4, chapter 28, "That she had already permitted him to make love to her he read as an additional assurance...love-making being here more often accepted inconsiderately and for its own sweet sake than in the carking, anxious homes of the ambitious, where a girl's craving for an establishment paralyses her healthy though of a passion as an end," states that Angel and Tess have already “made love.” Is this to be taken as it would be in today’s world, or does it simply refer to courtship?
Contrary to what Justin said about the strength of Tess, it seems to me as if, at least initially, Tess's altercation with Alec actually caused her to lose strength. Before Alec took advantage of her, Tess was willing to isolate herself from her family’s support in order to raise money to purchase a new horse. This took strength. After what Alec did to her, however, she soon retreated into her old home. She hid from the public. Slowly, she adjusted to her situation and strengthened. It was the humiliation, guilt, and critical eye of society that caused her to grow in strength, not the event with Alec. Finally, despite Tess’s increase in strength, we find in Phase 4 that she is still quite unable to forget the past. In my opinion, strength is the ability to be knocked down and still get back up and persevere. Thus far, I’m yet to see Tess do that.
Sorry Mitch, but i agree with justin on this one. I believe that Tess has grown stronger throughout our readings so far. We knew Tess when she was a simple country girl, and seeing her now in the text readers can tell that she has grown stronger. The whole situation with Alec was a temporary set back, but the situation helped prove her strength when she ended up having a son. Tess cared for him with dignity and took him to the fields with her to nurse him. Even though he was illegitimate and a mistake in society's eyes, she cared for him and loved him. Also the fact that her son ends up dying, and she has to bury him is a test to her strength. Most mothers having to do this would simply give up and not be able to carry on with life, but Tess shows her strength and maturity by decorating his grave and still being able to complete tasks in daily life.
Your comments are great - keep it up!
Ahhh... Sorry Nick and Justin, but liken in everything else in school, I think Mitchell is correct on this one. You see, I believe that the whole reason Tess has to move from her home in the first place to the Talbothay's dairy farm is so she can forget her past. She needs to leave her whole life behind her, because she is not strong enough to deal with the views that people will have of her in her present society. As Mitchell said, because she was not strong enough to go out into public, she secluded herself and only went out during the nights, which demonstrates that she had not grown stronger, but rather Alec had "broken" her, and made her weaker. As well, contrary to Justin's belief, I think that the reason that Tess does not marry Angel is because of her weakness, not her strength. I think that Tess is ashamed of the fact that she does not consider herself "pure" anymore, and she is too afraid to tell Angel about her past. I just think that the reason that Tess does not initially marry Angel is not because she is strong and true to her values, but rather she actually wants to marry him, but she is too ashamed of her past and too afraid of what a marriage would cause.
I definitely see what Mitch and Tim are getting at, and I agree with most of what you two are saying, however I still think that it truly does take strength to ATTEMPT to overcome one's past. And in opposition to what Mitch said, I believe that Tess really did "get back up" after being knocked down by being able to go out in public and take the criticism from everyone around her. I guess my point is that it takes a strong person to be able to ignore what people are saying about them, but an even stronger person to try to lead a normal life with that criticism.
In conclusion, kudos to Mitch and Tim, you've made me even more on the fence about my views on Tess than I was before. Good job guys...
Thanks Justin. Now seeing that the argument over Tess and if she has become "stronger" has basically concluded, I want to address Angel, and how he differs from his brothers. I believe Angel is very independent, and that his parents are somewhat prejudice. His family wants him to marry a women, Mercy Chant,not because he loves her, but because it would be beneficial for his social status. Angel has a lot of strength to somewhat "rebel" from his parents, and not just follow the same path his family did. He is strong in that he has his own beliefs, and the strength to pursue his own goals. Angel is very independent and strong-willed, and differs from his brothers and family greatly due to these characteristics.
To redirect all this Tess strength discussion to Angel's marriage proposal(s), I just have to say that I wanted to throw my book out a window when I saw that Tess refused Angel not just once, but basically every time he proposed to her or brought up the possibility of their marriage. I guess I sort of understood why Tess declined, but I feel like if she truly wanted to put her past behind her, she'd just tell Angel about her experience with Alec and move on to a happy life with him. It makes me wonder if Tess is strong or if she really is weak. If she was strong, she'd tell him the truth. Her refusals definitely made me think that she was on the weaker side at one point, but when I read the end of phase 4, it sort of changed my mind. I'm still on the fence regarding her strength, and I think that what happens after she tells Angel the truth and the decisions that she makes will determine whether she really is strong and can truly put her past to rest.
I guess this is one thing we can agree on Tim. I also believe that Angel is a very independent character and is somewhat of a rebel in the eyes of his family. But, I think the reason for this background is to show the reader that Angel is not the perfect person everyone claims that he is. Angel's character was put in the story to contrast Alec but it is also important to note that he is not completely good. Dont get me wrong Alec was much worse but Angel also posesses bad qualities because of his troubled past. Angel has these qualities to make him less god-like in the reader's eyes and more relateable to Tess. There would be no point in putting Angel in the story as Tess's love interest if he was perfect because this would make him untouchable.
Actually now that i think about it im doubting my agreeing with you Tim. I think that Angel is a fake rebel because he still cares about what his parents think. That is the only reason why he is trying to change Tess. If he truely didnt care what his parents thought about Tess, then he would stop trying to foce his beliefs on her. Overall i guess i believe that Angel's beliefs are too strong and that he is still trying to compete with his brothers for acceptance from his parents.
p.s. the physical portion of this fight can take place in lit second period tomorrow...be there
Jessica - if you wanted to throw your book across the room then, wait until you read Phase 5!! You'll need to think about that telling Angel and clearing everything up idea!
Returning to the issue of the strength of Tess, which I seem to be attached to, I think that at the end of phase four, Tess proves even weaker than before. For an extended period of time, Tess debates whether or not she should tell Angel about her past. In her heart she knows that telling him is the only way that she can get on with her life. Unless she is accepted by Angel for what she truly is, she does not feel she can be in a relationship with him. Then, after they marry, Tess yearns to tell him. In the end, the only time she can tell him is when she feels that she has been “let off the hook.” When she learns that Angel has also been sinful, she assumes that her sins will no longer be a big deal. Then, finally, she admits her sins. To me, strength is the ability to admit your wrongdoings and suffer the consequences. Tess can not muster the strength to do this. Instead, she waits and waits. Finally, when the consequences seem to have removed themselves, she admits what she has done, but this is a sign of weakness, rather than strength.
Didn't it take great restraint (strength) to NOT tell Angel about her past when she wanted to clear the air so badly?
Hello there fellow Tess readers. In answer to the OH MY! revelation at the end of Phase Four that Angel, himself, has violated someone as Alec did to Tess and Tess' subsequent exposure of her traumatic ordeal I would have to say "Finally". As you guys mentioned previously, Angel cannot be so pristine and perfect as to be unattainable (don't forget the foibles of the last character who was described as "nebulous"). So it does not come as a surprise that he has done such a heinous act. But his confession is probably good for Tess because it allows her to completely expose her past. But for heaven's sake, it took a ridiculously long time and I believe that them waiting till after they were married to tell their secrets will wrought an immense load of emotional suffering throughout the rest of the book. But we can always hope and prey that the tragic life of Tess will get better, can't we? (Though it probably won't, no actually, will clearly never improve.)
have you no hope for a happy ending?
Tess didn't tell Angel because of selfish reasons. She wanted him to continue to think of her as pure. She wanted to continue to be loved by Angel. Furthermore, I fonud it quite clear that Tess WANTED to tell Angel and didn't have the strength to do so, rather than wanting to tell and resisting. These are all signs of weakness.
jessica, i completely agree with you. i was really mad.
But that part of the story just kind of proves a point about how not strong she is. Tess can't even move on from her past and marry a man that actually treats her with dignity and respect up until this point. Question: how many times have you heard a story of a woman who has been raped and just gets over it and continues on with her life? Mitchell, i agree with the fact that I truly don't beleive that she was picked herself up from this experience. If she is supposedly "so strong", then why can't she tell of her past and move on? It is taking her all of her strength to tell Angel, and honestly, i don't know if she should trust him yet. A girl is entitled to her secrets, and i don't think she should be sharing them unless she is ready to be able to hold her head high and stand firm on the ground by herself.
I have to agree with your pessimism Monique, largely because the books we read in school never have happy endings.
true story.
In response to Mrs. Brown's original prompt, Tess's response to Angel's proposal is to lie and avoid. Initially, Tess responds to his proposal by stating that she only wants to love, but not to marry. Then she changes her defense by claiming to protect him from the scorn of his parents, who expect him to marry a woman of high social status. Later, she says she cannot marry him because of what his friends would think. She behaves this way to prevent Angel from marrying an impure woman, but she should have told him the truth from the start. He wasted time by continually seeking her affirmative response because she could not be honest about her past. I understand that it is difficult to reveal such a HUGE life secret, but if she really loves him she should be able to tell him such things- versus living haunted by a lie. Basically, I understand the reason for Tess's response to the proposal, but cannot agree with her actions.
I believe that Tess has grown weaker throughout the storyline of the novel. At first she resists all of the actions and innuendos that Alec sets upon her. Yet, as time passes, on the extended ride through the woods her vulnerability is revealed. From this, it seems as if Tess is allowing others to operate her life, as well as settling for the belief that her people support- that is, that "It was to be". From the primary action that was performed in the woods, there is a portrayal that "...social chasm was to divide our heroine's personality thereafter from that previous self of hers...", whereas never again would Tess return to her previous nature. Subsequently, hereafter, it appears as if Tess is submissive to Alec, even though she does not have romantic feelings toward him. Thus, the fact that Tess cannot stand up for herself as an individual despite tragedy creates a weak individual. In my eyes, if she wishes to be strong despite the event, she needs to utilize it as motivation to rise above conflict.
Also- the fact that Tess chooses to not reveal certain pasts and truths to Angel displays weakness. In order to have a strong relationship, one must share truths instead of denying or dodging them.
Mrs Brown, it is hard to chime in to a conversation of just three students...
Just choose any of the original questions and state your view. Or, make a new observation based on the recent reading.
How are your views of Angel changing as you read Phase 5? Is Angel's behavior justifiable or defendable?
A question Mrs. Brown brought up today in class is, "Is it wise for Tess to listen to her mom and keep her past a secret from Angel?"
In response to this I believe that it is very un-wise of Tess to listen to her mom and keep her past to herself. Earlier in the work Joan Durbeyfield wanted Tess to marry Alec D'Urberville for all the wrong reasons, the main one being for money. When Tess listened to her mom's advice about going and staying with the D'Urbervilles it ended with the rape of Tess. This displays Joan's inability to think through her thoughts and thus should not be taken seriously. Therefore I believe it is not wise for Tess to listen to her mom. Also, now that I have read about Tess and Angel getting married, I believe things can only get worse because Tess listened to her mom and did not tell Angel of her past. Sooner or latter the truth will have to come out but i doubt Angel will accept the fact that Tess was raped whole heartedly and may even begin to look down upon her.
As I read phase 5, my views of Angel defineatly changed. When he makes his second appearance in the book at the farm, I thought of him as someone that would help Tess get stronger. He is/was affluent, kind, and hard working, he seemed like the kind of person that would stick by her no matter what. After reading phase 5 though, I was really disappointed with how he reacted when Tess told him of her past. When he married her he made it sound like he would stand by her no matter what the circumstances, but when he leaves her just like that it really lowered him in my view; especially after he had relations with an older woman in London and he actually had a choice unlike Tess. Angel comes off as a progressive man for his time period, but is it possible between his decisions to become a farmer instead of going to college(likely the better prospect) against his parent's wishes and to leave Tess simply signs of his immaturity? Would he have asked Tess to marry him so soon with so few details if he wasn't so naive?
I totally agree with Ryan. Especially since Angel made his decision to have relations with a stranger, while Tess was totally vulnerable and nable to protect herself from the situation. It is incredible how much Angel changes from the veiw of the reader from phase 4 to phase 5, and it made me realize that Angel is not much less selfish and arrogant and disrespectful than Alec, if at all.
Concerning whether Angel loves Tess:
I think he absolutely loves her, no question. We see that when he is about to take Izz to Brazil and suddenly stops, choking up, and says that he cannot take her. It is obvious that he loves her, but his own pride and stubbornness stops him from admitting (or realizing) that he is wrong.
I'm really disappointed in the characters of this novel. First, Alec turns out to be a big jerk. Then Tess finds this wonderful man who is in love with her, and he ends up being a hypocritical jerk. I am especially disappointed with Tess. Although she has been taken advantage of by her family and Alec, she seems like she has no back bone. she allows others to walk all over her. I am hoping that with this quarrel between Tess and Angel, she stands up for herself, and learns from her many mistakes.
Caitlin, I agree that Tess looks weak right now. I believe in this part of the story Tess is portrayed as a weak character. For example, Tess begs for Angel's forgiveness after she tells him about his past. I believe that if she were a strong character, she would not need to appologize to him. Personally, I think the fact that she is appologizing is stupid. But, in my opinion if Tess were a strong character she would not have to run after Angel when he goes off into the night. In fact, I believe if she were a strong character she would be able to realize she is right and maybe walk out on Angel for a while. Everything that made me think Tess was a strong character has has been wiped out by this scene, leading me to think that Tess is a weak character.
As the novel progresses, all of us are disappointed to find out about how the major characters change in the novel and especially phase the 5th. However, i don't agree with the fact that Tess is weak. If Tess was weak, she wouldn't be able to live the life and do the things that she does. In my opinion, she is strong because she holds on to her beliefs and principles even in times of struggle and when in conflict with Tess. I think that, that Angel is the weak one, because he is unable to deal with Tess's confession. Tess knew that something bad was going to happen but she is always willing to compromise, where as Angel just always wants to see the good side of thins and is unable to see the bad and deal with it; that makes him a weak character.
I'm sorry if I'm backtracking but I need to talk about the end of phase the fourth and the beginning of phase the fifth. Angel admits to her that he spent two days with a stranger (probably no longer a stranger though), and Tess feels that she can finally come clean to him about the rape. So she does and he can't deal with it. ARE YOU KIDDING?? I understand that the social expectations for men and women were different in those days, and I give credit to Hardy who faced those head on, but as a female, I wouldn't have been able to deal with Angel Clare. I would have left him, but Tess doesn't have the strength to do that. So Angel goes. He has to leave her because he cannot bear to despise her. He goes to a different continent because she was raped. She couldn't control what happened to her and he couldn't control what happened, why does Angel think that leaving her is somehow going to help either of them?
In my opinion, Tess is a weak character. When Angel says that he cannot deal with the fact that she was raped, she follows him around. She even goes so far as to say that she thought about ending her life. She's thinking suicide because the man who claims to love her can't deal with the fact that she was raped. That doesn't make her strong. It makes her extreme in her reactions, but it doesn't make her strong. One way that she would show her strength is to leave Angel. If he can't love her because of something that she couldn't control, who needs him.
I completely agree with Amanda; no matter what time period or culture, is it really fair to leave the one you love because you can't handel their problems yet you expect them to handle yours? I think it is completely unfair for Angel not to handle Tess' problems. As Amanda said, Tess' situation was not her fault and Angel should be able to get over his now apparent chauvinism (though this may be too harsh of a description) and continue to love her. Hardy really captured changes in personaliity, especially on page 183 when Angel says after finding out Tess' secret, "I repeat, the woman I have been loving is not you". It is now prominant, especially to the reader, that the Angel we have previously been whitnessing was a persona. Therefore, i believe it is right for me to say phase five completely changed my opinion of Angel.
How have my views of Angel changed since reading Phase the Fifth? Well, for starters, I really love how accepting and sympathetic Angel is. NOT really! Actually I think how he reacted to Tess' revelation is a load of cuck. I agree with Amanda in that I acknowledge that those were different times back in them ol' days but come on, the fact that he can't be around her in fear that he may grow to despise her is ridiculous. And, instead of just leaving, he has to be so snide as he slips out the doorway and out of his commitments. He acts as if something has been done unto him which is as lucid as me riding a miniature pony on the highway. He has no right to blame Tess (especially if you remember that she tried to tell him her secret before he said "I do" and should thus take his situation with a grain of salt (how cliche). She isn't a different person as he seems to think and it does not give him the right to act moronically (asking Izzy to go overseas with him instead of his wife). His emotional response and his following reactions all seem to prove how imperfect he is and how vain every living person truly is. We can love others but we still only think of that person in regards of ourselves. How could Tess do such a thing to him? Well, how could he do such a thing to the women he so desperately pursued?
Im response to the first question about Tess being a strong person. i do not beleive that she was being strong, but i also think that not many people could be strong in that situation. After what alec did to her she tried to hide it as much as she could-this is not necessarily the "strong" thing to do-but i beleive that it is what anyone in that situation would do. I beleive that by her moving to the dairy farm represents her trying to run away from her past, and i do not blame her at all for doing this. I do think that Tess should of told Angel about her situation before they got married, but i can understand her concern about what he would think of her. I beleive that if she was strong in that situation she wouldn't of tried to her past and would of told Angel much sooner about what happenend. Although Tess did confess to Angel about what happened, i still beleive that he does love her. If he didnt, i dont think that he would send her money and still keeep the minnimal contact that they do have. He also seems to regret his harshness towards her by saying how "if only she [she] told me sooner". I think he understands that he screwed up, and so did she, and they both need to be forgiven for that.
To Mrs. Brown's question about how my views of Angel have changed...
I agree with many of the above bloggers that the view of Angel has shifted to the polar opposite of how he was introduced. I'm waiting for another turning point that may reveal why Hardy chose to make him this phenomenal person when first introduced and then the total characterization of Angel does a 180. His angelic nature and almost God-like characterization was hopeful for the reader; I thought Tess was on her way to a happy ending). It was horrible how Angel reacted to Tess' confession. Considering his actions, he's response to her story of the rape was cruel. It is also interesting how (from a literary standpoint) Hardy juxtaposes Alec and Angel. First, Alec is the bad guy and Angel is brought in as the savior. Then when Angel leaves Tess, Alec reappears at the end of phase the fifth. I am not sure why Hardy does this, but it may foreshadow something about how the relationship Tess holds with both Alec and Angel may change. No matter what happens, I am no longer a fan of Angel. His leaving Tess and reaction to her rape are awful and it left a bad taste in my mouth after this sudden turn.
In response to angel's transformation in phase the fifth:
I completely agree with Michelle, Monique and Amanda. I was shocked to find that Tess's acceptance of Angel's previous affairs was not reciprocal. It is hard to believe that anyone could be so narrow minded as to believe that a rape could possibly be the woman's fault. Not to mention that Angel considers Alec to be Tess's "husband in nature", despite her complete loath of Alec. In my opinion Angel's affair before their marriage is incomparable to the relation between Alec and Tess. Angel has completely reversed his previous disposition to become the same as, if not worse than, Alec. His outbursts of emotion reveal him for the man he truly is. Although he still has feelings toward Tess(otherwise he would have divorced her)her confession caused him to treat her as more of a servant who cannot be trusted. Overall, it is appaling to me that someone who seemed so good, acts completely opposite under a specific circumstance that should not even apply.
Something else that bothers me about phase the fifth is the way which Tess responds to Angel's overreactions. When Angel first reveals his anger toward Tess over her rape, she takes it and begs him for forgiveness for being RAPED?!?!? I cannot even begin to understand her reasoning. Perhaps she wishes to keep their marriage together at all costs, but still, her actions have left me puzzled. The second reason Tess shocks me in this phase, is when she considers killing herself because she feels bad that about the effects that her rape had on Angel. Again, I was baffled when I read this. I'm not sure, but perhaps this is how people in this time period viewed women's rights (as having none), but it is just unbelievable to me that a woman should be punished for being raped. This is yet another example of Tess weakening throughout the book, proving that she is not growing stronger as a person, but sinking into submission.
While reading Phase the Fifth I became outraged by Angel's reaction. I agree with you Heather, how can someone be upset with someone else because they were raped. Rape is defined as "any act of sexual intercourse that is forced upon a person" therefore it is absolutly ridiculous that Angel is ashamed and angry at Tess.
I think it is interesting though because his anger can be seen in individuals in our society. I think that back then it was a lot worse and that women had way fewer rights, but if anyone remembers in health class or self defense the teachers always tell you its not your fault if you're raped which implies that there might be people today who try to blame you for putting yourself in that situation or what not. So my point is...I don't think our society has changed all that much.
Tess I think is also very frustrating. I am mad that she didn't tell Angel before about the rape. If I were him I would be really mad too. How do you marry someone who has left out such an important detail. When I read Tess I feel like I'm watching a scary movie where I just want to tell the characters what to do because their every move just leads to negative outcomes.
Throughout the reading so far I agree with what heather says about Tess. She growing weaker as the story progresses and doesn't seem like she will change. If somebody is raped it means that there was no consent from one of the parties, in this case it was Tess. Then when Alec gets angry at her, she says she is sorry and wants to kill herself when it was beyond her control.
What I want to know is what Angel's true motive behind going to Brazil is about. Angel is having a big problem and I wonder if he is trying to get away from Tess. They both have a terrible past, so why is Angel trying to run from the problem instead of fixing it?
Reading Phase the Fifth made me extremely angry. Angel's reaction to Tess's confession was both uncalled for and hypocritical. How does he have the right to be mad at her for what happened? Tess was raped. Alec preyed on her and cornered her into a situation where nothing could be done to escape. Tess was a child; extremely naive to the evil ways of men, so she really can't be put at fault for what happened to her. Rape is not only physical abuse but mental as well. What happened to her was almost tragic, so Angel had absolutely no right to react the way he did.
Also, Angel confesses to having had an affair with an older woman, which in his eyes in completely forgiveable. But for some reason, Tess's rape is not forgiveable? I hate that society puts a double standard on certain situations. It's okay for a man to sleep around at his will, but if a woman is not pure, in any sense of the word, she is considered to be a bad person.
I feel the same way Ariel does. Angel should have never acted the way he had. he abandoned Tess in her time of need. He just got up and left.
Everyone is innocent until proven guilty. Tess should not be treated as a bad person but as a good person in a bad situation. I think the only wrong and bad person here is Angel.
coming back to Angel's character...When i think back at all that has happened in Angel's life and all the decisions he made, i come to the conclusion that his character has not changed at all. Angel has always chosen to take the easiest way out of things and to make his life as easy and comfortable as possible. i think that a lot of it has do to with his background. His family is wealthy and he did/does not really have any problems and always 'got what he wanted'. I think that never before in his life had he had to deal with something like Tess's confession and that simply overran him. He did not know what to do because in his life up to then he had never faced hardships really and always got what he wanted, at least that was what he thought. Tess on the other hand had to deal with hardships all her life and she is 'used to' having to deal with struggle; furthermore in her life, Tess always worked thinks out to the best of her ability and even though she might not have always been happy, she still knew how to deal with struggle. That is why i think this marriage was doomed for failure and also the fact that they act totally different in this time of crises is no real surprise.
In responce to Fredrick, i think that the angel is portrayed as a contrast to Alec thus forcing us to think that Angel was different and kind.As i was reading i had two different view of him.Angel's reactions to the other dairy workers actions and thoughts of him tells us that he does not resist to the different treatment he gets from them. i think that he contrast his own views of disapproving family name and wealth by his acceptance to the different behavior that he get from the dairy farmers and the owner of the farm. the second view was that he was the kind and supporting person that tess needed. I really think that Angel is the weaker one who cannot accept the fact that tess is not all that perfect.The fact he expects tess to live with the past in which he was invovled with an older women while he cannot accept the fact that Tess against her will was taken advantage of by Alec shows that he is the weaker one. i also agree that it should not have been a big surprise that angel has reacted that way because he is someone who expects things to work in his favour and so far in his life he had all the benifits.
In response to how my views have changed about Angel......
I found a very strong passage in Phase the Fifth about Angel's true feelings toward Tess. When, on page 198, Angel's sleep walking and talking is being discussed i found that this event is the basis to Angel's true thoughts of Tess. Like Tess states in this passage, Angel has a tendency of sleep talking and walking about prior events that happened that day because his conscience refuses to let his days experiences end. Thus when Angel found out Tess's past his true feelings come out in his sleep talking and walking and he says sadly out loud "'Dead! Dead! Dead!'". This reveals that the Tess he used to know is know non exsistence and essentially dead to him because her past shadows over any other characteristic he fell in love with in Tess. Therefore we find that Angel cannot get over Tess's past and we learn that nothing she can do will change that. Lastly, also within that passage, we learn that Tess realizes Angel's true feelings because she knows that his sleep talking and walking are a continuation of his stream of thought from prior events. Overall i found this to be a great passage and one to keep in mind as we move forward in the text.
I beleive that a major part of Phase five is when Angel is leaving to go to Brazil and asks Izz to go along with him. Izz tells him that Tess "would have laid down her life for 'ee" and this seems to have an impact on Angel. As soon as he replays that in his mind, he decides that he should not bring Izz along with him to Brazil. I think the fact that he decides not to take Izz to Brazil shows something about his charachter, maybe foreshadowing something between him and Tess at the end of the novel.
The collapse of Tess & Angel's marriage certainly has two sides to it, and I would like to address the one that we have focused on less frequently.
What could Tess have done to prevent Angel from 'abandoning' the commitment they made to eachother?
After Angel shows disdain for Tess' past - the fact that she was raped, and then gave birth to a child that died shortly afterwards - she completely submits to his will in the hopes that her submissiveness will draw him back towards her. This effort fails miserably. Tess then endures Angel's wanton cruelty, until they part ways indefinately.
Could not Tess have attempted to maintain her dignity, instead of groveling in front of Angel - the one who actually sinned - for forgiveness she did not even need?
I would have to agree with Ryan. Much of Tess's suffering is self induced. She allows the guilt of her past rule over her present life. She feels that she is always in the wrong. It is not Tess who should be punished for events that are out of her control, but she remains submissive to Angle.
Tess says "i agree to the conditions, Angle, because you know best what my punishment ought to be,"(204) She is not in control of her own life. Tess is letting the men in her life ultimately control her happiness and well being. Maybe Tess should make some decisions that will benefit her, instead of worrying how they will reflect upon Angle.
Is this social commentary?
In response to Becca's question, I do think this could be considered social commentary, or just commentary on human nature in general.
From the few details i know concerning this time period, I believe that Hardy is stating that women too often give up their sense of independence and self-importance when they enter what they hope to be a "successful" relationship. Since the marriage turned sour only hours after the rings were exchanged, Tess panics. Her idyllic relationship with Angel seems impossible now, but because of her deep love for him, and her still-strong desire to be committed to him, it never occurs to Tess to seek happiness elsewhere. Divorce was something still frowned upon in Tess' time, so I am sure other moral beliefs related to marriage and "purity" were entrenched throughout society at that time.
Purity seems to be an important attribute in a women. Maybe the reason we view Angles reaction towards Tess so negatively is because we live in a different time period. It seems a sin to inflict such pain upon a delicate young woman's hart, even though you have committed the same sin. It always has been, and it always will be more socially excepted for males to engage in certain scandalous behavior, then it is for women. In modern times women like to be though of as strong and equal, but in the time of Hardy women were supposed to be submissive and weak.
Do you think that Tess's submissiveness would be perceived as the right thing to do during the release of the novel?
dear becca,
an interesting question you bring up. I don't necesarily know whether Tess's submissiveness would have been the right thing to do; most importantly, i think it was her only option. Historically, the spirit of women has obviously evolved to the point where we are considered equally to men. But in the age when Tess was written, i don't think there would have been much of another true way to react. I imagine that it would be an extreme minority of women that would have acted differently than tess had the same experience happened to them. They didn't have options like we do. The options and opportunities available to people (in this case women) have increased dramatically as the world has gone on. Among other things, i think it's this modern day opportunity is the reason our world is so advanced.
So i tell myself- the opportunity we have in our world was created by US...if tess HAD acted differently, would she have created a positive opportunity for herself to prevent bad things from happening in her future?
I agree with Jenny on her response to Becca's question. I believe Tess's response was more of a must rather than the right thing to do. During the time this book was first published, 1891 anyone wanted to know, women didn't have much of a choice in regards to being submissive to their male counterparts. I think Tess made the right decision in her mind, based on the culture and time period. And now that decision would be viewed as maybe weak or the wrong thing to do. But we must consider the culture of the time period, in which women were not equal to men and did not have the oppuritunties they have now. So Tess in her mind, did what she thought was right in order to survive and not become an outcast in society. Now looking back we can argue that she should have been more assertive and not taken it, but she probably thought she had no choice.
In response to Jenny's question I think that if she had been assertive and not submissive the result would most likely be negative for her. I think that could have occurred is that her response of being assertive is that she becomes more of an outcast in this society which during the time is ruled by men. Like mentioned before men during this time period, were in charge and did what they want pretty much without punishment. It is even seen in the novel Alec rapes Tess and she instead of telling authorites like people would now, keeps what happened hidden. And most likely if she did assert herself would probably would have been dismissed. So I think that by acting assertive could have caused her more problems than being submissive. Speaking against men in that time period usually caused women to be outcasted and chastised. This could have created a hostile enviroment for Tess. The possiblity of having men who run society hate or black list you could have ruined your life and any oppuritunity you had could have been shattered. And if that happened she would probably have to leave the place and move somewhere else to escape that situation. So I think acting and being assertive poses more of a risk than a benefit.
I also have to agree with Becca and Jenny. Within the time period of Tess women were seen as merely objects that men could acquire. The women was meant to be pure and honest and really had no say in their own lives. Angel had some form of control over Tess, he was her husband after all and at this time that meant everything, and since he decided that he could no longer live with her it seems like her only option was to accept it. What could Tess really do anyway? Angel had made up his mind about how he felt towards her, it isn't like she could convince him to forgive her (I don't think forgive is the correct word, it wasn't her fault). Angel had decidedthat he could no longer bear to be with Tess and there really isn't anything that she could do but submit to his decision.
Mrs. Brown I forgot to put my name on the comment right above this one. So yeah the anonymous one above this is also mine.
P.S. Who doesnt love Tess? I couldn't stop reading!
Angel and his brothers differ in the respect that his brother's chose the path set by their father and Angel decided to do his own thing.
Angel's brother's lives seem to be better than his because though Angel is living the way he wants he is making mistakes and paying for them. For example, if Angel just gave in and married Mercy Chant than he would have been assured of her purity and wouldn't be on his way to Brazil to escape his wife. In choosing to follow their father, Angel's brother chose an easier life for they really don't have to make any decisions. The brother's may be letting the father lead their lives but they don't have to worry about making life changing mistakes- even if they do, their father will be there to help them.
Since Angel chose to lead his own life, it seems like he can't really go back to his family for support when things go wrong because he didn't heed their advice and made decisions based on his heart where his family made them with success in mind.
I'm not saying that being told what to do is the best life today, but at this time knowing that your family would be there to worry about things and essentially do your thinking seems like a better life than running away from the one you once loved.
In response to Sean's comment; yes, Angel did decide against bringing Izz with him to Brazil, but the fact that he even asked her to accompany him allows us to see more of his true character (along with abandoning Tess)than that decision.
As I read on in Tess, I find it more prevalent that there is weakness present. First, Tess is willing to do anything for Angel in order for him to accept her now that he is aware of her past. Tess' amount of dignity in this passage is to the point of zero, whereas she diminishes herself fully by willingly sacrificing all of herself for Angel. Also, later on throughout the book, there is a weakness in attendance that is presented in a different fashion. The subtitle of Phase the Sixth clearly states the idea- that "The Woman Pays". That is, when Tess begins to have interactions with Alec once again, the text notes and implies that the mere fact of Tess' attribute of being a female is hereby an unfortunate disadvantage. This is because while Alec is involved in the same episode that occurs in the past, he moves on and experiences a "conversion" into a religious persona. He even gains the consent of a preacher. Yet, Tess remains a social flaw, even though the episode that she experiences with Alec is a far lower degree her fault than Alec's. Furthermore, the simple point that Alec has the nerve to exploit Tess is a sheer demonstration of disrespect of the female.
Apologies if I’ve repeated a previous topic explicitly posted (I don’t think I did, nor did I mean to); same to if I used quotes from your previous comments without permission…
As I gleaned over the past comments and discussions, I couldn't help but notice the assertions and defenses of Angel's actions as well as the idea of Tess's strength. Regardless of whether or not Tess's problems or desperation is self-inflicted (are they?), a reader must admit that she seems to continually fall into situations where she is left with no well-defined path of recovery to follow. In that, I think that we’ve been fooled by our author into supporting Angel Clare, while despising his supposed foil, Alec D’Urberville. While we’ve been looking at the handsome, well-mannered, self-questioning man, we’ve also been directed to look away from his flaws. To be honest- the fact that Angel has left Tess, somewhat on her own, doesn’t surprise me. Why? Simply because he (Angel) is a lot more alike Alec, than we’ve given him credit for. Timmy, Amanda and Monique all hinted at it previously, stating “it made me realize that Angel is not much less selfish and arrogant and disrespectful than Alec, if at all,” or similar ideas. In this discussion alone, Angel has gone from a character we love, to a character we love to hate, and now ends as a character with the benefit of the doubt. Yet we have to question, whatever happened to the girl that he slept with previously..? Did she end up in a similar situation as Tess? Given, she wasn’t raped for 48 hours (we assume) but still – How does a glorified man such as Angel leave her to fend for herself…and now he leaves Tess… How does Angel’s decision to become a farmer mirror Alec’s to be a minister? Angel was characterized by Nick as a “fake rebel” because he still cares what others think of his actions… Couldn’t you characterize Alec the same way? Neither of them has much of a family support system, but both come from well-to-do families. Tess seems to attract a particular type of man. The fact that perhaps Angel is a few years ahead of Alec on the time-line (in terms of personality maturity) is troubling. How similar do you think Alec and Angel ultimatley are? Do the circumstances under which they’ve acted excuse certain faults?
I have very mixed emotions about each character in this story. They each act one way which causes the reader to believe that's who they truly are, and then some event happens where my point of view of them is totally distorted. i have no idea what to think of the characters in this story anymore. For example, Angel was originally a sweet guy who i thought was perfect for Tess. (Maybe he still is perfect for her? i don't know.) then he abandons her because she came clean, which was a jerk move, but THEN he tells Izz he cant take her with him to Brazil because of Tess, which is nice and almost shows a bit of his fidelity to Tess.
I must admit that Michael brings about a good point. Tess, over the course of the novel, has attracted two men with disturbingly similar qualities. I agree that the author has obviously set them as foils (Angel's name only adds to that fallacy), but in the past few sections, they are just variations of the same. Alec may be the lesser of two evils! At least he is open about his flaws, where as Angel's are more hidden behind his fabulous facade. We have been drawn to his character since his introduction. Does anyone remember meeting him? He was checking out EVERY girl dancing around in a white dress! He is totally a womanizer, just like Alec. Perhaps Angel did knock up the weekend fling of his past, and maybe she is just like Tess: striking, not from a wealthy family, considered of "poor breeding," and the seemingly stereotypical small town, field hand girl.
But, if Tess attracts these men to her, mustn't she also be drawn to them? She acknowledges them, courts them, and puts everything into her dysfunctional relationships. I think her men-problems also stem back to her father, the town drunk. It is common for a woman to end up in a relationship with a man similar to her father. When her mother was young, she was like Tess (beautiful, small town, etc.). Isn't it possible that families then are rather cyclical? They recreate similar arrangements and then play the roles of their parents. I am not asserting that this is the case throughout the history of every family, but if the role Tess is playing is the only role she has been exposed to, how would she know to behave differently?
I agree with Lydia about the characters (especially Angel) being rollar coasters. Throughout the plot, be are pushed one way then pulled in another when it comes to our opinions on the characters. A good example of this would be when Angel sends money to Tess to care for her, yet leaves the country. If he was completely heartless (as many have hinted), he would not care for her wellbeing; yet, he DOES. However, this care is very very limited since he refuses to accept her apologies. For me personally, i feel very little sympathy for Angel; i refuse to try understanding his reaction. It was selfish and hypocritical.
For Becca and Ryan :)
Yes, Tess could have acted differently...in theory. I agree the time period has a great impact on her character as a whole, and maybe she WAS trapped.
But, the idea that her suffering is self-induced is absolutely intoxicating. Wouldn't that change the entire story? This would mean that the cards have always been in Tess' hand. Therefore, we would be forced to turn away from dwelling on the immorality of the men that traipse around after her (or away from her I suppose) and study her with the criticality reserved for psych ward worthy patients.
Instead of the naive country girl, repeatedly abused by upper class men, we would essentially be left with a masochist furtively plotting her own demise!
Michael, I think that your questions brings up a good point, which I disagree with Sophia on. I feel that Alec and Angel are very different. First, Angel does check out every woman at the dance in a white dress, however this does not make him a womanizer. He is still a single man at this time. Shouldn't he be able to check out other women? I think that even though Alec and Angel may have hurt or used Tess, they are very different because of their circumstances. Alec simply planned on using Tess for his sexual desires, whereas Angel actually liked Tess. This is obvious through the rape of Tess compared to the marriage of her. One of the most common qualities between both men seems to be their arrogance, believing themselves to be higher than Tess. This is seen through Angel's lack of forgiveness for Tess. Once again, I disagree with Sophia on the fact that she is drawn to these men. Its seems to me that she was only really drawn to Angel, whereas her "relationship" with Alec was merely one way. Although I do like the thought about her problems stemming from her father.
From what is stated above, both men do have some similar qualities, yet I feel that the circumstances make the audience slightly more lenient with Angel. Alec performed his own actions out of lust, in comparison to Angel who performed his out of shame.
Now a question: If Angel is so willing to run away, did he actually ever love Tess the way the audience was meant to believe?
I strongly disagree with Dylan. Angel and Alec both took advantage of a woman or participated in illicit relations with one. For all we know, like Sophia said, Angel could have completely taken advantage of whoever he slept with for those 48 hours. I agree that Angel isn't a womanizer, but I think that his wealthy background, along with Alec's, and their position as superior men in society make them acceptable in the eyes of society during Tess's time, and almost in our time as well. The only way that the characters differ is that Alec owns up to his mistakes and tries to reform himself while Angel keeps his secrets from Tess and doesn't even seem as ashamed of what he did as he should be. Both men want Tess in some way; both are in love with her. However, I don't think that Angel really loves Tess herself; I think that he loves the idea of her and the purity that comes along with that. Regardless of whether Angel got whoever he had sex with pregnant and regardless of the different kinds of love they have for Tess, both men are similar. They are arrogant and self-important and deserve an equal amount of hatred or dislike from the reader.
Answering Dylan's question, I definitely think that the reader's idea of Angel's love for Tess has completely changed. If he truly loved Tess herself, not just her looks or "purity", he wouldn't have abandoned her. Marriage means that you stick together for better or worse. Obviously Angel doesn't love Tess the way the audience was supposed to believe if he ran away, like a coward, to Brazil. I understand that he feels betrayed, but really? Brazil? That's on a completely different continent. Yes, he probably needs some time to recover, but he essentially did the same thing. His love for her has completely transformed.
I definitely think that Michael's comparison of Angel and Alec was both right, relevent, and thoughtful. Both men had affairs with women they had no intentions of marrying as well as treated Tess poorly. But I would have to agree with Dylan that we, the readers, tend to overlook Angel's flawed character. I think the inner-romantics in all of us want to believe that somewhere deep inside of Angel lies the respectful and wonderful man that Tess fell in love with at the farm.
In response to Dylan's question, I do believe that Angel loves or loved Tess in a true way. But i think that he just didn't want to hear that there was any other man in Tess's life before him. He is a human being. We are stubborn and resentful, and tend to hold grudges for periods of time. I would like to think that he will, at some point, get over himself enough to go back and treat Tess the way that she deserves to be treated.
to Dylans question i have to say that i think that if Angel truly loved Tess then he would be able to overlook what has happened in the past and be able to forgive her. i think you do find that being with a person is accepting them for all their flaws because that is what makes them perfect. Tess was able to deal with the fact that he himself has not always been the greatest, so why shouldnt he feel the same?
to some extent though he does love her because he did consider not leaving and going back to find her.
to compare angel with alec though is a different story, alec just wants someone to be with and im not so sure that he actually will love that person. angel is the type that will find something that he can relate to and have a relationship with.
In response to Dylan's question and Jessica's comment.
I agree with Jessica that the audience has very different views of Angel after he ran away. But now that Alec is back in the text as a main character again (as we get into phase the sixth) it's again interesting to see different "sides" to him. At first, he seems transformed, like his work in the church and with his faith have helped him become a better man. But as he talks and begs and pleads, I just find him annoying. He took advantage of Tess once, and I can only hope it doesn't happen again. But I think he is mostly back to being a womanizer and a control freak. I think his encounter with Tess at this point in the story will bring out in him the characteristics the audience is most familiar with.
And I don't think I believe that Angel really loved Tess. I think he was made up to be a phenomenal rescue after Alec. But when he chose to run away, that doesn't scream committment. He has other intentions, as we learn when he conefesses to being with another woman, and I don't think his intentions with Tess could have been far off. Maybe it is in the context of the time period that makes it hard to gauge whether Angel loves Tess. He may have, but in our current society, when you run away from the past or the truth, it mostly means you don't care enough to stick around.
Something else that I find interesting as we move into phase the sixth is Tess' hesitation to write to Angel. On page 257 (chapter 46) there is a brief paragraph that describes Tess writing a letter to Angel and then simply putting it away, thinking he will not care. I'm wondering if this relates back to her being a stong character. She is married to the man and cannot find it within herself to write to him. She doesn't have to speak face to face, doesn't have to listen to a response, just has to let him know what's going on. If she cannot tell her own husband of her feelings and desperation, how will she ever find anyone else to trust. I understand that she's a difficult position, but I think she needs to tell Angel what she's feeling. We have said in class that because of the time period, the man is more or less supposed to be dominant and the woman compliant to his wishes. If that is what Angel wants (since we can somewhat agree he too loves the control) then he should respond and come to protect her. She'll never know until she finally sends a letter.
In response to Jessicas opinion concerning Dylans comment...
Angel really does love her, he says to his mother " she lives what paper-poets only write" (pg131) meaning that Angel is captivated by everything Tess does, he loves the way she is, her outlook on life, he loves her for her personality.
Alec doesnt really own up to his mistake, and feels no remorse until we see him again in Phase 6.
And you are mistake about Angel having no remorse, on page 180 he says "you will see what a terrible remorse it bred in me when...I myself fell." He also explains that he felt the same torture and desire to confess himself to Tess in the same way that Tess did. "He seemed to be her double!"
Finally, how can you say Angel does not love Tess when he chokes up at the mention of her love for him? As well as when he was sleepwalking and demonstrated the love that he could not show in his waking hours.
In agreement with Michelle, i also find Alec extremely annoying. From the very beginning of phase the sixth, i find his turn towards religion false and conceited. It is so quick that it is unbelievable to the reader. Alec's infactuation with Tess slowly turns to obsession, with multiple examples throughout chapters XLVII, XLVIII, and L. Throughout this entire phase, i am creeped out for Tess. I think that Alec's obsession is over the top and makes the reader uncomfortable. As much as Tess has been pushing away Alec, there seems to be underlying foreshadow that eventually Tess will be sucked into the web Alex has spun around her. even if it is just for the sake of her family, i fear that Tess' life is going to take yet another turn for the worst. If only Angel could have understood Tess is at no blame for what happened to her, Tess' life would not be as miserable as it has turned out.
Theres too much drama in this book. People need to chill out man, Angel in particular. "oh no, my wife had sex with another man before she married me?! Oh wait, so did I(with a woman though)...But I'm gonna shun her for life and go to Brazil with some other chick anyway." What a joke, thats not cool at all. I think that one of the main reasons I find myself saying that the characters need to relax can be based on the difference in time periods, similar to Michelles response concerning Angel's love for Tess.In Tess's time period,previous sexual relationships before marriage were looked down upon and purity of a woman was valued. In our society, not so much, at least I believe. But on the other hand, I agree with Michelle in her statement that Angel did not really love Tess. In all honesty I hate Angel. And I hate Alec to. They're both idiots when it comes to treating women, believe me I know ;). Basically we all know by now that they want to get some. However, Alec is the kind of guy who is more strightforward about it whereas Angel is the kind that will stick around, walk the walk,talk the talk and hope all goes well when the time comes to go to bed at night if you know what I mean. Come to think of it, I hate Tess right now as well. What a pushover. Stop letting guys play around with your heart and start sticking up for yourself and demand a little respect. That is all.
to back up my response, i've heard that in today, the percent of Americans who have premarital sex is about 90%, so based on that how do you think Angel's reaction would be viewed in todays society? I think he would probably seem kind of crazy for ditching Tess over something like that.
Well, since everyone should be reading Phase 6 tonight, I feel it's appropriate to comment on it. Emotion plays a big role in my perception of each character in this section.
First of all, in Chapter 47, I felt proud of Tess when "she passionately swung the glove by the gauntlet directly in [Alec's] face" (Hardy 267). I hate the way Alec is so pushy while pursuing Tess, and it's nice to see her sticking up for herself. However, I felt angry reading this section when Tess seems to give into Alec and believe he may be her only hope. It upsets me to read that Alec believes that by helping Tess she will forgive him for raping her. Also, as irritating as the seperation between Angel and Tess is, I'm rooting for them, and Alec's seduction makes me hate him even more! Except that is not to say that Angel is not at fault- he frustrates me. Why doesn't he just come home already?! He needs to get over himself and fulfill his duties as a husband. In addition to feeling proud of Tess and angry at the men, I was sympathetic while reading the letter Tess writes to Angel on page 271. She finally finds courage to plead for forgiveness and profess her unfaltering love for Angel. Furthermore, I pity Tess for the hardships within her family [pathos :-)]. Overall, my emotions regarding occurences in Phase 6 has changed or intensified my perceptions of the characters in this text.
In response to Matt's question, personally I think that in today's society Angel would probably be called stupid for leaving a girl that's as beautiful and angelic as Tess is for a reason like that. Then again our society is extremely different in it's view on divorce. On the extreme end of things we have the celebrity crowd who marry and divorce constantly. This is emulated by the public in the mindset that "the stars did it so it must be ok". However, in our society people usually leave over money or just plain hating each other, not the girl's virginity. Besides, if we did go by that, then the large majority of the women in America and probably the world would never be married. Going back to Angel, he would be called stupid for leaving her because of his reason but not looked down on for actually leaving her. Again this is because the society of Tess cares alot more about marriage than we do today.
A huge smile crossed my face as I saw that becky had quoted: "she passionately swung the glove by the gauntlet directly in [Alec's] face" (Hardy 267). If she hadn't I definitely would have had to have brought it up. To all you guys who insist Tess should take a stand- is that what you meant? In response to the first question about Tess posted (has she become stronger throughout the text) this part of the text can be taken two ways. 1) YES! she finally grew a backbone that leads to a brain and did something that she can be proud of! (that she still apologizes for..) OR 2) No! She's let her emotions get the better and is acting out of anger/desperation. She's weaker and now she is just getting by. This shows it clearly. Which is stronger in your opinion (1 or 2)? I personally think that by this action she display her weakness as a person. She lost her composure. Sure - it was provoked following unfortunate circumstances.. But still - she lost it. She's been worn.
In response to Zoe..
With the ways things are going in Tess' life i guess we can say that the reintroduction of Alec is a foreshadowing of something bad about to happen. His "love" for her really has manifested into an obsession as seen in Phase 6 where he finds her on multiple occasions and refuses to give up on asking her to marry him. Alec honestly has become a stalker and appears almost constantly everywhere Tess goes: her garden, the church Tess and her family sleeps in when they cant find lodging, Candlemas, and plenty of other places. He also seems to be doing almost anything to get Tess to like him, becoming a clergy member, offering his house to her family when Tess' father dies, giving up on being a clergy member when it shows that Tess could care less, helping her in her garden while her mom is sick, etc. His willingness to do ANYTHING to get Tess to like him (even force her) is almost pathetic to the point you almost feel a little sorry for him. At this point I can see Hardy taking the story in two different directions. Either Angel makes it back in time and saves Tess from Alec or Tess does something by herself to rid herself and her family of Alec. I personally am leaning toward Tess doing something that gets rid of Alec but also makes her life worse because the majority of the book is basically about Tess' suffering how crappy her life is. It doesn't seem likely that Hardy will give Tess another large period of happiness like before she told Angel her secret and the life she enjoyed with him. So my question is this, do you think Tess' life will get worse than were its at now or do you think that Hardy will end the story in a positive "happily ever after" way?
Quick comment
I completely agree with Michael. Tess' reaction simply proves how broken she is and how she can never fully overcome the past.
Wow, Michael. That is quite the conundrum. However, I feel the question of Tess's strength is a wishy-washy concept. She appears solid, then cracks later. It depends on how one views actions (in regards to time periods and gender-appropriate ideals). In accordance with Michael, I don't think that after Tess's "uppercut" it really proves that she has become stronger. In my opinion, some kind of passionate outburst, verbal or physical, is the kind of attention Alec wants. It's what he feeds on, and by her acting out in aggression it just entices him more. No one can really justify striking someone else as a righteous action to prove a point. She pretty much hits Alec to shut him up because she doesn't want to hear him whine about how his personal shortcomings are her fault. Tess needs to rise above her scapegoat position, but she won't do it by smacking people, even if they deserve it. In my opinion, the stronger person would have taken the higher road and realized that she is better than stupid squabbles about nonsense with cretins that can't move on with their lives.
Does anyone else find that Tess continually seems to be portrayed as a scapegoat for everyone else's personal failures? First her father and mother blame her for not doing her duty to the family by marrying a noble cousin, then Angel can't accept her rape but is relatively guilt free from his little escapade, and now Alec can't get past her "haunting image" corrupting him out of his religious burst of zeal? I'm really finding Hardy to be obnoxious in this sense, but it is just proving a point that women were pretty much doormats to contain dirt and other unpleasant things from ruining the bigger picture. Props to Hardy for realizing the degradation of women, but will he ever make Tess rise to the occasion?
I agree with Chryssa, it seems as though Tess is always used as a scapegoat in the three cases of Alec, Angel, and her parents. The story is starting to get old and repetitive as far as how the events rise and fall in action and we are given the same portrayal of women as nothing but mothers and housewives during the time period. After the first few phases i hoped that the plot would become more interesting, but it is just more of the same in a new scenario.
In response to Zoe, i am at the same point in Tess right now, and i think that Alec is acting very unlike himself. But hey, this is back then, who knows, maybe people's personalities were capable of radical change in life philosophies. Afterall, this is the same society in which a man will not have a non-virign for a wife, however himself is not pure either. I think that Alec's behavior is foreshadowing of something bad to come, but through all of the twists and turns that have been going on throughout the novel i think it is capable of going both ways, in unexpected favor of Tess, or predictable disappointment for tess.
This comment is a little off the topic of the blog but through out the book since Tess' child died, i have wondered why Hardy has not mentioned her sorrows about her child later on in her life. I mean I am aware that she is trying to move on (or run away) from her troubles; but a person can not just forget about a being that they pushed through their utterus and gave life to. Maybe this is just Hardy's way of revealing a different phase in Tess' life, and mentioning the child would keep her stuck in the past. But I do just find it slightly strange that Tess never thinks about her child besides when she tells Angel her awful past. And when she tells Alec about his child.
I agree with what Chrysa said about Tess being the scapegoat, but i never really realized it until i read her post. I don't think that Hardy is portraying her like this just because she is a woman though. I think it has more to do with how she is-i do not think that she is being strong-not her gender. I think that if she was stronger as a person she would stand up for herself and not be allowed to be the scapegoat. She should stand up to Angel because he was more in the wrong than she was...she had no choice to get raped. I agree that she is used as a scapegoat a lot, but i do not feel like it is just because she is a woman. I beleive that he is just portraying a weak character to maybe emphasize how tough her life has been. I do agree with Chrysa though that Hardy is making her look like a big scapegoat in almost every situation.
Through the beginning of phase six it seems unclear of Alec's true intentions. Has he really found God? Do you think that Alec is a wolf in sheeps clothing?
No matter how hard I try I really do not like Tess. She is an annoying little whinner baby to me. Especially when Angel was pursuing her, Tess would just not let herself be happy. And now she is without a husband, and back to where she started with Alec being a fool; claiming to have found God. I find the characters in Tess very simlar to other literary works like The Scarlett Letter. Tess is very similar 2 the chick who had to wear the letter (her name escapes me at the moment). And Angel is like Hawthorne. Angel starts to become mentally unstable, and corrupt like Hawthorne. What is it about love and lust that brings about characters downfalls?
In response to Michael M and everyone else who answererd his question:
I definitely think they're many similarities between Alec and Angel. To what extent they are similar is a debatable, but I won't dwell on that. I want to look at the big picture. It seems to me that the social commentary Hardy makes with the Alec/Angel situation is that no man is guiltless of fault or sin. Throughout the book, I've noticed countless instances of symbolism that would suggest Hardy has a disdain for religion, well Christianity specifically. By building Angel up to be a glorified, nebulous character and fooling the audience into believing Angel will be the one to save Tess, Hardy succeeds in demonstrating the true, undeniable nature of man. Almost to say, that in dire (sp?) situations, man reveals his true colors.
Personally, I think everyone picks on Tess because they're viewing her from a present day standpoint. In retrospect, it's very easy to understand why Tess is the way she is. In the 1890s, the words "women" and "right" were seldom put together, unless one is giving directions or idealizing a perfect woman.
If one accounts for the audience that the book was targeted towards, Hardy's obviously trying to play upon the emotions of women who have been hurt by codes of man. The audience sees how the selfish whims of society treat women like Tess. Yeah, it'd be great if Tess was like, "Whatever, I don't need Angel. I can be my own person without family or spouse" but that was unheard of for the times. Even today, some women can't bring themselves to do that.
Wow! What insightful comments today. I love the strong opinions whichever way you feel toward Tess or Hardy! This is just what I had hoped for in your involvement with the text.
One thing that angered me about this book is how Tess is being blamed for the incident that happened between her and Alec. I do not think that Angel has the right to be mad at her because he did the same thing only willingly, woman or man it is inevitably the same act. Tess did not want this to happen to her and she had no way of stopping it, so why is she punished for something she had no control over? I think that it makes a good topic to talk about in discussions about the book and helps develop the book, showing the reader the way women were viewed. But, as a topic, I fully disagree with it and it angers me knowing the double standard that we have in society back then and today, that men can get away with the exact same thing a woman does, but the woman is punished for it.
Throughout Phase Six Alec keeps coming back to Tess, begging her to marry him. My question is is why is doing this now after all this time? Does he really love Tess or does he just want forgiveness from God for what he has done? Tess is angry that he has become such a religious man because she thinks he has done this on account for what he did to her, so he can promise himself a spot in heaven by becoming a religous man and asking for forgiveness. Does Alec really deserve a "spot in heaven" after what he did to Tess? Causing her so much pain and suffering, even years later.
"Tess is very similar 2 the chick who had to wear the letter (her name escapes me at the moment)" -Chelsea
Hester Prynne?
Anyways, Rob and Chrysa were talking earlier about Tess' role as a scapegoat. While I think this is an important way of viewing her at this point in the book, it bothers me that no one seems to be talking about what the book is screaming at me. Tess was wrong! I am not trying to be insensitive, she has had a terrible history. Nonetheless, is Angel really such a bad person for being bothered by Tess' secrecy with regards to her past? Wouldn't you want to know if your fiance had been raped and had had a child before she met you? I for one would have felt hurt that she had not trusted me enough to share with me one of the most significant events of her life.
Note that this is not because of her history itself, it is her lack of trust that is important.
as to what caitlin is bringing up, i think that alec might have grown up more in the time that we havent heard from him. i mean who knows what he had gotten into when we didnt hear from him. if he became more involved with the church, or his mother actually started caring for him he might have realized that he needs to be more caring to those he loves. and with that he is trying to win tess back over.
or maybe he is very jealous of the fact that angel married her first. i really dont know.
Caitlin has a valid point in saying that Tess faces a double standard with regards to what is acceptable for men to do and what is acceptable for women to do, and in reminding us that Angel had the luxury of a choice in the matter.
At the same time, we must remember that Angel was more straightforward about his actions than Tess. Is this because he trusts her more, or because as a man he can act without fear of the consequences?
The above post was mine. Forgot the last name
With regards to Tiff's post I don't really trust Alec because of Tess' history with him. He has not truly reformed as much as he thinks he has--if he truly cared about her he would apologize and then stay out of her life.
Like john just said, i think that being straightforward is beneficial in the end. i can see where alec keeps coming back to tess because he loves her, and in part i do think this is justified. i admire his willpower and determination to win over tess; however, he tends to go about doing this rather arrogantly and way too forcefully.
in the end, i'm thinking i admire angel more for the way he handled his situation with tess. though he went a little too crazy about tess's history, i suppose it's legitimate because of the time period. and most importantly, angel seems to have a great consideration for tess. his thoughts and actions don't belittle her or treat her like a prize like alec's. Even seperating himself from her, i believe, was a decision angel made after serious thought to not only his best interest, but to tess's. he avoided other alternatives that would have been far more ruinous to both of them. sooo classmates, do you agree?
I think that alec should of never left tess in the first place. It was very hipocritical of him to leave her in the first place for what she had done. he had done the same thing and he left her just because she waited awhile to tell him the truth. She really does love him alot and she shouldnt let herself give in to him and let him come back into her life.
Also in response to what Chelsea F said a little bit ago about tess and how she didnt like her becuase shes a whiny little baby? I dont think that is true at all. i think that she is actually quite tough being able to make it through all the things that she has had to go through in her life. she was pretty much raped by alec and had a baby and everything and she was able to make it through that and allow another man into her life. and then after she did so he hurt her and left her after she needed him the most and she loved him so much. so i think that tess is rather tough and has great perserverence and i thinkk she should not let alec back into her life no matter how much he begs but i know it must be hard for her because of how much she loved or loves him.
In response to Jenny, I think that Alec keeps coming back to Tess because he loves her but it is kind of like he is stalking her. He just shows up at different places where she is. He expects her to completely forget that he raped her, and forgive him and possibly actually marrying him. I think that Alec hasn't really changed that much he is just disguising himself so it seems like he is a better person.
Everyone has been talking Alec down so much, which is understandable considering what he did to Tess earlier, but if you think about it, he is going through the exact same thing as Tess. Alec is asking for forgiveness and for Tess to forget his past, to judge him on who he is now. Even though Hardy portrays he demonically even now, Alec looks to me a lot like Angel did when Angel was trying to win Tess's hand in marriage. Angel is being a wuss over in Brazil, too childish to face his problems and solve the situation at hand, while Tess and Alec both are trying to win forgiveness. Wouldn't it be hypocritical to hope Angel forgives Tess, while hoping Tess never forgives Alec?
In response to josh r, i agree that Tess is not really a baby, she is pretty strong. She has been through a lot over the course of the entire book. She was raped, and then had a baby who died not long into its life. After finding a man who actually respects her, she is plagued with the guilt of everything with Alec. I think that Angel is very hypocritical because he told her about his "fling" and expected her to forgive him, but when she tells of her misfortune he blows up. As much as I could hope that Angel will realize that he is wrong, and come back to Tess, I don't really think that it will really happen. I think that maybe deep down he is not really husband material.
I agree with Katie about how Alec hasn't changed. He may have said that he's been "enlightened", but I think that was obviously a bunch of crap. He's still the same. He obviously wants Tess even more than he did when he was obsessed with her at first because he can't really have her now since she's married. I think that Alec's obsession or love, whatever you want to call it, has gotten worse. Some of the things he says hints that he might even view her as property. For example, he says, "'Remember, my lady, I was your master once!...I will be your master again. If you are any man's wife, you are mine!" on page 267. In addition, he also tells her, "'Mind this; you'll be civil yet!'" on page 294. Alec also takes advantage of a weak spot: her family. I don't think that it is fair that he tries to make her give in to him by saying that he'll help her family, which definitely needs help, especially after her father dies. Alec hasn't changed in the slightest bit; he's probably gotten worse.
In response to brooke e's comment, i agree completely. although it seems rather strange that we advocate the forgiveness of alec considering his inappropriate actions in the past, i see the "hypicritical" point you are trying to prove. It seems this book is filled with hypocracy. First, when Angel runs to Brazil, vowing never to forgive Tess and telling her what a terrible and unexcusable thing she has done- yet he too has done the same things. I feel strongly that this reflects the nature of Victorian society. Men and woman were held to double standards, and Hardy makes this clear. This is exemplified each time Tess encounters Alec, portraying her as a temptess and resposible when clearly this is not so. Thus, the victorian era seems filled with hypocracy and inequalities. And yet... doesn't it seem permissable that this hypocracy continues? I do not blame Tess for not forgiving Alec, because i feel his act was inexcusable, taking from her one of the few rights she has as a woman in the victorian era. However, I feel Angel needs to forgive Tess as he doesn't have such grounds to be angry... as he is the hypocrite himself. So wouldn't you agree, that even hypocracy has standards and limits of what is acceptable and what isnt?
I agree with John R in that Alec should apologize and stay out of Tess' life but i dont think that would ever happen because of his obsession with her. He seems to have changed in his religious views but when it comes down to being with Tess and not being with her those views that he holds now are out the window. After reading phase the sixth i think that Alec might be a stalker as someone else said and that his obsession for tess is unhealthy and that he should just move on and accept that she is with another man now, even though he is not there (Angel).
In response to Morgan, I just dont see why Tess doesnt forget about Angel like he has forgotten about her. He does not forgive Tess for her actions and though im not sure whether Tess knows about what Angel did...? but i think that that would be a more than acceptable reason to forget about him and move on but as Morgan was saying it was the Victorian Era and everything was different and they had different views on these things. Also there was the thing that Alec should not be angry at Tess because he has no right to be. I agree with this and think that she did not harm Alec as much as he harmed her so that she was right in telling him to go away and that he shouldnt have gotten mad and kept on being persistent in his actions.
In response to Sanjeev J:
I understand what you are saying, and this is my initial reaction as well. But after considering it further i have decided that Tess has very little to lose. In her time of need, if Angel will not accept her, provide for her, and love her... then why not take another chance with Alec? He obviously is willing, and right now she needs some security, as marriage to him would provide. It seems that Tess cannot get worse off or more unhappy as she is basically identityless as each phase continues. As far as the self respecting thing to do, tess should realize she doesn't need men in her life (and clearly from her past she would be much happier that way)... yet whether it be due to time period or her strength of character, this doesn't seem like an option. Tess should not allow Angel to make her miserable, especially from so far away... i feel like it is time she does something for herself, and if alec is truly the temptation that she writes about to Angel... then perhaps he COULD be just what she needs. (But to be clear, i'm still not an Alec fan!!!)
I completely agree with Katie M. In class we've described Alec as a "creeper" and I think he proves that true now more than ever. He pops up constantly and even has gone so far as to ask Tess to marry him. I don't believe he's been "enlightened", but instead sees it as a way to get closer to Tess- or so he thought.
Morgan, what you say makes sense, but im not so sure i agree. I concur that Tess needs to get over it; it really is ridiculous that she has milked this sympathy for so long. However, im not so sure the way to go about this is through marrying Alec. His religious epiphany is completely fake; he will not provide support and love, but rather more mental abuse. He makes her feel vunerable (in a negative way) and she can do better. She should be able to turn her pain and misery around WITHOUT the help of a man. Yes i kno her family could use the financial help, there must be other options that do not involve Tess losing her dignity.
well how much more value does dignity have over your own family that you see suffering in fron tof your eyes!!! i believe that at that situation i would sacrifice my own diginity inorder to help my family. tess's first reason for working for Alec was to help her family with finance!! so i think that dignity has no value over a family in extream need!!
I am so impressed with the quantity and quality of the comments! Keep up the good work.
my comment
Post a Comment